城市污泥中重金属存在形态、去除及稳定化研究进展

doi:10.16085/j.issn.1000-6613.2017-0775

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 城市污水处理厂污泥产生量大，含有丰富的有机质、氮、磷、钾等农作物所需营养物质，但由于受重金属的污染使污泥无法直接农用。本文简述了城市污泥重金属的来源、特点及危害。重点论述了城市污泥中重金属去除和稳定方法，包括化学法（电化学法、化学试剂法）、生物法（微生物法、植物法、低等动物法）、物理法（超临界流体萃取、微波和超声）及联合技术。分析了各种方法处理污泥重金属过程中重金属的形态变化及其对处理效果的影响，对比各种方法的优缺点、影响因素及适用范围。指出污泥中重金属形态分布是影响去除效果的关键因素，污泥中重金属形态分布差异性大，且大部分重金属以稳定或相对稳定的状态存在，导致物理法和生物法去除效率较低，微生物和低等动物处理法相比植物法（备受时空限制）则表现出更好的适应性；电化学法对可氧化、可还原态分布的重金属都能起到较好的转化去除作用，但往往受由污泥向污泥液相中转移过程的控制，电损耗较突出；化学试剂浸提剂是目前效率较高的方法，但强酸环境常导致污泥营养物质流失和酸根离子累积，农用时容易板结而不利于污泥土地利用。因此，以土地利用为前提的条件下，将各种处理技术联合运用以提高污泥重金属去除率有待于进一步研究。

关键词: 城市污泥, 废物处理, 重金属污染, 去除, 稳定, 赋存形态, 电化学

Abstract: Municipal sludge is rich in organic matter and nutrients for plant growth such as N, P and K. But it can not be directly used in agriculture as a result of the contamination of heavy metals. In this paper, the origins, characteristics and hazards of heavy metals in municipal sludge are described briefly. The removal and stabilization methods of sludge including chemical, biological, physical and the combination methods, are discussed emphatically. The effects of the methods on the speciation and removal efficiency of heavy metals in sludge treatment process are analyzed. In addition, the merits and weaknesses, influence factors and application scope of these methods are compared. The results show that the speciation of heavy metals is the most critical factor that influences the removal of heavy metals from municipal sludge. There are great difference in the speciation of heavy metals to distribute in sludge and the most of heavy metals existing in stable or relatively stable state, which leads to low efficiency of physical and biological method on heavy metals removal. It is noteworthy that microbial method and lower animals treatment has a better adaptability compared with plant method owing to the limit of space and time. Although heavy metals both in oxidizable and reducible speciation could be effectively transformed and removed, the electric energy consumption is quite outstanding due to the domination of heavy metal transfer from sludge into liquid phase. At present, chemical extraction is currently the best method. It is, however, difficult to utilize treated sludge due to nutrient loss and acid ions accumulation of raw sludge. Consequently, jointly using all kinds of processing technologies in order to improve the removal efficiency of heavy metal from sludge under the premise of land use remains to be further research.

Key words: municipal sludge, waste treatment, heavy metal pollution, removal, stabilization, morphological changes, electrochemistry

中图分类号:

X705

解道雷, 孔慈明, 徐龙乾, 徐晓军, 李天国, 段正洋, 刘树丽, 刘伟. 城市污泥中重金属存在形态、去除及稳定化研究进展[J]. 化工进展, 2018, 37(01): 330-342.

XIE Daolei, KONG Ciming, XU Longqian, XU Xiaojun, LI Tianguo, DUAN Zhengyang, LIU Shuli, LIU Wei. Developments of the speciation, removal and stabilization of heavy metals in municipal sludge[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2018, 37(01): 330-342.

参考文献

[1] 国家发展改革委,住房城乡建住部. 《"十三五"全国城镇污水处理及再生利用设施建设规划》[EB/OL].[2016-12-31]. http://www.ndrc.gov.cn/zcfb/zcfbghwb/201701/t20170122_836133.html. National Develop and Reform Commission,Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of People's Republic of China. The use of facilities planning in "13th Five-Year" national urban sewage treatment and recycling[EB/OL].[2016-12-31]. http://www.ndrc.gov.cn/zcfb/zcfbghwb/201701/t20170122_836133.html.
[2] 方平,唐子君,钟佩怡,等. 城市污泥焚烧渣中重金属的浸出特性[J]. 化工进展,2017,36(6):2304-2310. FANG P,TANG Z J,ZHONG P Y,et al. A study on leaching characteristics of heavy metals in sludge incineration slag[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress,2017,36(6):2304-2310.
[3] YANG G,ZHANG G,WANG H. Current state of sludge production,management,treatment and disposal in China[J]. Water Research,2015,78:60-73.
[4] PRETEL R,SHOENER B D,FERRER J,et al. Navigating environmental,economic,and technological trade-offs in the design and operation of submerged anaerobic membrane bioreactors(AnMBRs)[J]. Water Research,2015,87:531.
[5] 张辉,胡勤海,吴祖成,等. 城市污泥能源化利用研究进展[J]. 化工进展,2013,32(5):1145-1151. ZHANG H,HU Q H,WU Z C,et al. Research progress of municipal sludge energy utilization[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress,2013,32(5):1145-1151.
[6] PETRIE B,BARDEN R,KASPRZYK-HORDERN B. A review on emerging contaminants in wastewaters and the environment:current knowledge,understudied areas and recommendations for future monitoring[J]. Water Research,2015,72:3-27.
[7] DU F,FREGUIA S,YUAN Z,et al. Enhancing toxic metal removal from acidified sludge with nitrite addition[J]. Environmental Science & Technology,2015,49(10):6257-6263.
[8] 孙娜,商和平,茹淑华,等. 连续施用污泥堆肥土壤剖面中重金属积累迁移特征及对小麦吸收重金属的影响[J]. 环境科学,2017,38(2):815-824. SUN N,SHANG H P,RU S H,et al. Effects of continuous application of sewage sludge compost on heavy metals accumulation and mobility chaeacteeistics in soil peofile and on heavy metals uptake of wheat[J]. Environmental Science,2017,38(2):815-824.
[9] MOISE I,STEFAN C,JITARIU D,et al. Aptitude of soils in limitrophe romanian black sea coastal area to urban sludge application as agricultural fertiliser[J]. Journal of Environmental Protection & Ecology,2012,13(2):972-978.
[10] LACHASSAGNE D,SOUBRAND M,CASELLAS M,et al. Impact of sludge stabilization processes and sludge origin(urban or hospital)on the mobility of pharmaceutical compounds following sludge landspreading in laboratory soil-column experiments[J]. Environmental Science and Pollution Research,2015,22(21):17135-13150.
[11] 张灿,陈虹,余忆玄,等. 我国沿海地区城镇污水处理厂污泥重金属污染状况及其处置分析[J]. 环境科学,2013,34(4):1345-1350. ZHANG C,CHEN H,YU Y X,et al. Pollution characteristics of heavy metals in sludge from wastewater treatment plants and sludge disposal in Chinese coastal areas[J]. Environmental Science,2013,34(4):1345-1350.
[12] 姚金玲,王海燕,于云江,等. 城市污水处理厂污泥重金属污染状况及特征[J]. 环境科学研究,2010,23(6):696-702. YAO J L,WANG H Y,YU Y J,et al. Pollution status and characteristics of heavy metals in sewage sludge from municipal wastewater treatment plants[J]. Research of Environmental Sciences,2010,23(6):696-702.
[13] 杨倩倩. 城市污水污泥中重金属的物化浸提及其形态研究[D]. 哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学,2010. YANG Q Q. Extraction of heavy metal in municipal sludge with chemical and physical method and modality heavy metal[D]. Harbin:Harbin Institute of Technology,2010.
[14] 霍庆霖,徐小逊,张世熔,等. 蚯蚓消解后污泥的性质变化及对彩叶草生长的影响[J]. 生态与农村环境学报,2016,32(1):126-132. HUO Q L,XU X X,ZHANG S R,et al. Properties of earthworm digested sewage sludge and effects of the sludge on growth of coleus blumei[J]. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,2016,32(1):126-132.
[15] HASSAN W,DAVID J. Effect of lead pollution on soil microbiological index under spinach(Spinacia oleracea L.) cultivation[J]. Journal of Soils and Sediments,2014,14(1):44-59.
[16] 明银安. 城市污泥果肥利用研究[D]. 武汉:华中科技大学,2009. MING Y A. Study on utilization of municipal sewage sludge fruit fertilizer[D]. Wuhan:Huazhong University of Science and Technology,2009.
[17] CHEN H,TENG Y,LU S,et al. Contamination features and health risk of soil heavy metals in China[J]. Science of the Total Environment,2015,512/513:143.
[18] 萧晨霞,胡勤海,田耘,等. 氨络合法电化学捕集去除城市污泥中重金属的研究[J]. 中国环境科学,2014,34(11):2874-2880. XIAO C X,HU Q H,TIAN Y,et al. Electrokinetic deposition and removal of heavy metals from sewage sludge enhanced with ammonia complexation[J]. China Environmental Science,2014,34(11):2874-2880.
[19] 郭广慧,陈同斌,杨军,等. 中国城市污泥重金属区域分布特征及变化趋势[J]. 环境科学学报,2014,34(10):2455-2461. GUO G H,CHEN T B,YANG J,et al. Regional distribution characteristics and variation of heavy metals in sewage sludge of China[J]. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2014,34(10):2455-2461.
[20] 涂剑成. 污水厂污泥中重金属脱除技术及污泥特性变化的研究[D]. 哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学,2011. TU J C. Study on removal of heavy metals from sewage sludge and change of sludge characteristics[D]. Harbin:Harbin Institute of Technology,2011.
[21] MARQUES A,RANGEL A,CASTRO P. Remediation of heavy metal contaminated soils:an overview of site remediation techniques[J]. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology,2010,41(10):879-914.
[22] 袁华山,刘云国,李欣. 电动力修复技术去除城市污泥中的重金属研究[J]. 中国给水排水,2006,22(3):101-104. YUAN H S,LIU Y G,LI X,et al. Treatment of heavy metals in municipal sewage sludge by using electroremediation technique[J]. China Water & Wastewater,2006,22(3):101-104
[23] 周邦智,吕昕,赵小辉. 剩余污泥中重金属的电动力学修复研究[J]. 环境工程学报,2011,5(6):1401-1404. ZHOU B Z,LU X,ZHAO X H,et al. Research on electrokinetic remediation of heavy metals in surplus sludge[J]. Chinese Journal of Environmental Engineering,2011,5(6):1401-1404.
[24] KIM S O,MOON S H,KIM K W,et al. Pilot scale study on the ex situ electrokinetic removal of heavy metals from municipal wastewater sludges[J]. Water Research,2002,36(19):4765-4774.
[25] YUAN C,WENG C H. Electrokinetic enhancement removal of heavy metals from industrial wastewater sludge[J]. Chemosphere,2006,65(1):88-96.
[26] WANG J Y,ZHANG D S,STABNIKOVA O,et al. Evaluation of electrokinetic removal of heavy metals from sewage sludge[J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials,2005,124(1/2/3):139-146.
[27] 顾祝禹,艾克拜尔·伊拉洪,吐尔逊·吐尔洪. 电化学方法去除污泥中重金属的研究[J]. 环境科学学报,2014,34(10):2547-2551. GU Z Y,AIKEBAIERYILAHONG,TUERXUN TUERHONG,et al. Removal of heavy metals in sludge by electrochemical treatment[J]. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2014,34(10):2547-2551.
[28] CAI Z P,DOREN J V,FANG Z Q,et al. Improvement in electrokinetic remediation of Pb-contaminated soil near lead acid battery factory[J]. Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China,2015,25(9):3088-3095.
[29] KUAN Y C,LEE I H,CHERN J M. Heavy metal extraction from PCB wastewater treatment sludge by sulfuric acid[J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials,2010,177(1/2/3):881-886.
[30] 曾祥峰,王祖伟. 乙酸-铁氧体共沉法处理城市污泥中的重金属[J]. 环境科学与技术,2009,32(1):143-146. ZENG X F,WANG Z W. Heavy metal removal from municipal sludge using acetic acid-ferrite sedimentation method[J]. Environmental Science & Technology,2009,32(1):143-146.
[31] JUNG I S,LOVITT R W. Leaching techniques to remove metals and potentially hazardous nutrients from trout farm sludge[J]. Water Research,2011,45(18):5977.
[32] 吴赛霞. 复合酸浸法去除城市污泥中重金属的研究[D]. 武汉:中国地质大学(武汉),2011. WU S X. Removal of heavy metals from municipal sludge by combined acid leaching method[D]. Wuhan:China University of Geosciences(Wuhan),2011.
[33] 郭睿,王超,杨江月,等. 螯合絮凝剂EPPCX的制备及对Pb²⁺、Cu²⁺捕集性能研究[J]. 环境科学学报,2017,33(4):1396-1403. GUO R,WANG C,YANG J Y,et al Preparation of heavy metal chelating flocculant EPPCX and its removal performance for pb²⁺ and Cu²⁺[J]. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2017,33(4):1396-1403.
[34] 刘佳. 绿色有机酸和螯合剂萃取水厂污泥中典型重金属的研究[D]. 长沙:湖南大学,2012. LIU J. Study on extraction of typical heavy metals from sewage sludge by green organic acid and chelating agent[D]. Changsha:Hunan University,2012.
[35] 尹雪,陈家军,蔡文敏. EDTA与柠檬酸复配洗涤修复多重金属污染土壤效果研究[J]. 环境科学,2014(8):3096-3101. YIN X,CHEN J J,CAI W M. Evaluation of compounding EDTA and citric acid on remediation of heavy metals contaminated soil[J]. Environmental Science,2014(8):3096-3101.
[36] 吴青,崔延瑞,汤晓晓,等. 生物可降解螯合剂谷氨酸N,N-二乙酸四钠对污泥中重金属萃取效率的研究[J]. 环境科学,2015(5):1733-1738. WU Q,CUI Y R,TANG X X. Study on extraction efficiency of heavy metals in sludge by biodegradable chelating agent glutamic acid N,N-two acetic acid four sodium[J]. Environmental Science,2015(5):1733-1738.
[37] 谢礼国,郑怀礼,吴幼权. 等. 粉煤灰改性及钝化污泥实验研究[J]. 土木建筑与环境工程,2010,32(1):120-4. XIE L G,ZHENG H L,WU Y Q,et al. Modification and application of fly ash for the stabilization of sludge[J]. Journal of Civil Architectural & Environmental Engineering,2010,32(1):120-124.
[38] 李翔,刘永兵,宋云,等. 石灰干化污泥对土壤重金属稳定化处理的效果[J]. 环境工程学报,2014,8(8):3461-3470. LI X,LIU Y B,SONG Y,et al. Effect of lime-stabilized sludge on stabilization of heavy metals in soil[J]. Chinese Journal of Environmental Engineering,2014,8(8):3461-3470.
[39] 吴烈善,曾东梅,莫小荣,等. 不同钝化剂对重金属污染土壤稳定化效应的研究[J]. 环境科学,2015(1):309-313. WU L S,ZENG D M,MO X R,et al. Immobilization impact of different fixatives on heavy metals contaminated soil[J]. Environmental Science,2015(1):309-313.
[40] BABEL S,DACERA D D M. Heavy metal removal from contaminated sludge for land application:a review[J]. Waste Management,2006,26(9):988-1004.
[41] 王宇霞,郝秀珍,苏玉红,等. 不同钝化剂对Cu、Cr和Ni复合污染土壤的修复研究[J]. 土壤,2016,48(1):123-130. WANG Y X,HAO X Z,SU Y H,et al. Remediation of heavy metal contaminated soil with different amendments[J]. Soils,2016,48(1):123-130.
[42] 吉顺健. 污泥固化/稳定化处理对重金属形态的影响[D]. 南京:河海大学,2008. JI S J. Effect of sludge solidification/stabilization treatment on heavy metal speciation[D]. Nanjing:Hohai University,2008.
[43] 刘辉,刘月娥,庞桂林,等. 城市污泥重金属含量分析及稳定化研究[J]. 环境科学与技术,2012,35(6):114-117. LIU H,LIU Y E,PANG G L,et al. Heavy metals in municipal sludge:analysis and stabilization[J]. Environmental Science & Technology,2012,35(6):114-117.
[44] 韩雪峰,赵宝福,朱彤. 腐殖酸对污泥中重金属的稳定化研究[J]. 非金属矿,2016,39(4):35-37. HAN X F,ZHAO B F,ZHU T. Effect of humic acid on stabilization of heavy metals in electroplating sludge[J]. Non-Metallic Mines,2016,39(4):35-37.
[45] WU C H,KUO C Y,LO S L. Removal of metals from industrial sludge by extraction with different acids[J]. Journal of Environmental Science & Health Part A:Toxic/hazardous Substances & Environmental Engineering,2004,39(8):2205.
[46] STYLIANOU M A,KOLLIA D,HARALAMBOUS K J,et al. Effect of acid treatment on the removal of heavy metals from sewage sludge[J]. Desalination,2007,215(1):73-81.
[47] KOROLEWICZ T,TUREK M,CIBA J,et al. Speciation and removal of zinc from composted municipal solid wastes[J]. Environmental Science & Technology,2001,35(4):810.
[48] BAYAT B,SARI B. Comparative evaluation of microbial and chemical leaching processes for heavy metal removal from dewatered metal plating sludge[J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials,2010,174(1/2/3):763.
[49] DENG J C,XIN F,QIU X H. Extraction of heavy metal from sewage sludge using ultrasound-assisted nitric acid[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal,2009,152(1):177-182.
[50] 黄亮,周启星,张倩茹. 柠檬酸、草酸和乙酸对污泥中镉、铅、铜和锌的去除效果[J]. 应用生态学报,2008,19(3):641-646. HUANG L,ZHOU Q X,ZHANG Q. Removal effects of citric acid,oxalic acid and acetic acid on Cd,Pb,Cu and Zn in sewage sludge[J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,2008,19(3):641-646.
[51] 张华,朱志良,张丽华,等. 天冬氨酸和柠檬酸对污泥中重金属萃取的比较研究[J]. 环境科学,2008,29(3):733-737. ZHANG H,ZHU Z L,ZHANG L H. Extraction of heavy metals from sewage sludge using aspartic acid and citric acid[J]. Environmental Science,2008,29(3):733-737.
[52] 田宇,邓忠良,宁寻安,等. 制革污泥固化稳定化处理[J]. 环境化学,2012,31(1):94-99. TIAN Y,DENG Z L,NING X A,et al Solidification/stabilization treatment of tannery sludge[J]. Environmental Chemistry,2012,31(1):94-99.
[53] 黄玉娥. 污水污泥中重金属去除方法研究[D]. 长沙:湖南大学,2007. HUANG Y E. Study on removal methods of heavy metals in sewage sludge[D]. Changsha:Hunan University,2007.
[54] 谭险夷. 丝状菌对生物淋滤去除底泥中重金属的促进作用[D]. 长沙:湖南大学,2011. TAN X Y. Promoting effect of filamentous bacteria on bioleaching of heavy metals in sediment[D]. Changsha:Hunan University,2011.
[55] 霍敏波,郑冠宇,梁剑茹,等. 生物沥浸处理中微生物菌群和胞外聚合物对城市污泥脱水性能的影响[J]. 环境科学学报,2014,34(9):2199-2204. HUO M B,ZHENG G Y,LIANG J R,et al. Influence of microbial flora and extracellular plyometric substances on municipal sewage sludge dewaterability enhanced by bioleaching process[J]. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2014,34(9):2199-2204.
[56] 李淑更,张可方,周少奇,等. 微生物淋滤法去除城市污泥中重金属的效果[J]. 生态环境学报,2009,18(1):111-115. LI S G,ZHANG K F,ZHOU S Q,et al. Removal efficiency of heavy metals in sewage sludge by bioleaching method[J]. Ecology and Environment Sciences,2009,18(1):111-115.
[57] 李桃,周俊,李伟,等. 生物沥浸对自然干化污泥重金属去除效果研究[J]. 环境科学学报,2016,36(2):569-575. LI T,ZHOU J,LI W,et al. Removal of heavy metals from natural dried sludge by bioleaching method[J]. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2016,36(2):569-575.
[58] 黄明,孙兴福,许立巍,等. 生物沥滤去除城市污泥中重金属的温度控制研究[J]. 中国给水排水,2011,27(7):18-21. HUANG M,SUN X F,XU L W,et al. Temperature control in bioleaching heavy metals from sewage sludge[J]. China Water & Wastewater,2011,27(7):18-21.
[59] SHENG G P,XU J,LUO H W,et al. Thermodynamic analysis on the binding of heavy metals onto extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) of activated sludge[J]. Water Research,2013,47(2):607-614.
[60] 高洁,周永刚,张琪,等. 污泥耐受性草本植物的筛选及其对重金属Cu、Zn的富集[J]. 环境工程学报,2013,7(1):351-359. GAO J,ZHOU Y G,ZHANG Q,et al. Selection of herbaceous plants to sludge tolerance and their enrichment properties to heavy metals(copper and zinc)[J]. Chinese Journal of Environmental Engineering,2013,7(1):351-359.
[61] 刘周莉,何兴元,陈玮. 忍冬——一种新发现的镉超富集植物[J]. 生态环境学报,2013(4):666-670. LIU Z L,HE X Y. CHEN W. Lonicera japonica Thunb.——a newly discovered Cd hyper-accumulator[J]. Ecology and Environmental Sciences,2013(4):666-670.
[62] HUANG J W,POYNTON C Y,KOCHIAN L V,et al. Phytofiltration of arsenic from drinking water using arsenic-hyperaccumulating ferns[J]. Environmental Science & Technology,2004,38(12):3412.
[63] 萧晨霞. 电动力方法联合化学络合法强化捕集去除城市污泥中重金属及回收产物的研究[D]. 杭州:浙江大学,2015. XIAO C X. Removal of heavy metals and recovery products from municipal sludge by electrokinetic method combined with chemical complexation method[D]. Hangzhou:Zhejiang University,2015.
[64] MEAGHER R B. Phytoremediation of toxic elemental and organic pollutants[J]. Current Opinion in Plant Biology,2000,3(2):153.
[65] YANG J,ZHAO C,XING M,et al. Enhancement stabilization of heavy metals(Zn,Pb,Cr and Cu)during vermifiltration of liquid-state sludge[J]. Bioresource Technology,2013,146(10):649.
[66] 周波,唐晶磊,代金君,等. 蚯蚓作用下污泥重金属形态变化及其与化学生物学性质变化的关系[J]. 生态学报,2015(19):6269-6279. ZHOU B,TANG J L,DAI J J,et al. Remediating effluent sludge with earthworms:changes in heavy metal speciation and associated chemical and biological properties[J]. Acta Ecologica Sinica,2015(19):6269-6279.
[67] 周丽丽. 剩余污泥重金属脱除及资源化利用新工艺[D]. 湘潭:湘潭大学,2012. ZHOU L L. New technology of heavy metal removal from waste sludge and its resource utilization[D]. Xiangtan:Xiangtan University,2012.
[68] ZHANG X,TIAN Y,WANG Q,et al. Heavy metal distribution and speciation during sludge reduction using aquatic worms[J]. Bioresource Technology,2012,126(6):41.
[69] SHI W,LIU C,DING D,et al. Immobilization of heavy metals in sewage sludge by using subcritical water technology[J]. Bioresource Technology,2013,137(6):18-24.
[70] YANG C Y,DING Y G,DING Y,et al. Supercritical carbon dioxide chelating-extraction of trace heavy metal from calcium lactate[J]. Advanced Materials Research,2011,233/234/235:1402-1405.
[71] ARAIN M B,KAZI T G,JAMALI M K,et al. Speciation of heavy metals in sediment by conventional,ultrasound and microwave assisted single extraction methods:a comparison with modified sequential extraction procedure[J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials,2008,154(1/2/3):998.
[72] 涂剑成,赵庆良,杨倩倩,等. 超声辐射协同草酸-HEDTA浸提污泥中重金属[J]. 中国环境科学,2011,31(8):1280-1284. TU J C,ZHAO Q L,YANG Q Q,et al. Ultrasonic-assisted extraction of Cu,Zn,Ni and Cr in municipal sludge with oxalic acid and HEDTA[J]. China Environmental Science,2011,31(8):1280-1284.
[73] PENG G,TIAN G,LIU J,et al. Removal of heavy metals from sewage sludge with a combination of bioleaching and electrokinetic remediation technology[J]. Desalination,2011,271(1/2/3):100-104.
[74] ZHU Y,ZENG G,ZHANG P,et al. Feasibility of bioleaching combined with Fenton-like reaction to remove heavy metals from sewage sludge[J]. Bioresource Technology,2013,142(4):530-534.
[75] 张海英. 利用花卉修复污泥重金属污染的研究[D]. 长春:吉林农业大学,2013. ZHANG H Y. Study on remediation of heavy metal pollution in sewage sludge by flowers[D]. Changchun:Jilin Agricultural University,2013.
[76] 叶涛,黄丽,张克强,等. 皂角苷和柠檬酸联合去除厌氧消化污泥中重金属的研究[J]. 环境科学学报,2017,37(5):1798-1807. YE T,YUANG L,ZHANG K Q,et al. Combined removal of heavy metals from anaerobic digested sewage sludge by saponin and citric acid[J]. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2017,37(5):1798-1807.
[77] 胡亚杰. 电动力学法去除污泥中重金属研究[D]. 洛阳:河南科技大学,2013. HU Y J. Removal of heavy metals from sewage sludge by electrokinetic method[D]. Luoyang:Henan University of Science and Technology,2013.
[78] LIPHADZI S,KIRKHAM M B. Heavy metal displacement in EDTA-assisted phytoremediation of biosolids soil[J]. Water Science & Technology A:Journal of the International Association on Water Pollution Research,2006,54(5):147-153.