Research progress in MOF-based catalysts for electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction to ammonia

doi:10.16085/j.issn.1000-6613.2022-1042

Abstract

Abstract:

The production of ammonia by electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) at room temperature has attracted extensive attention due to its low energy consumption. So far, the research focus is to design highly efficient electrocatalysts. Metal organic framework (MOF) and their derivatives have wide applications in gas capture, separation, and catalysis due to their unique porous structure and controllable compositions. This review first discusses the mechanism of NRR, and then focuses on the research progress of NRR electrocatalysts of MOF and the derived materials. Finally, we summarize and prospect the design strategy, existing problems of the MOF based NRR electrocatalysts and the challenges in NRR catalysis. In addition, this review points out that: ① The reasonable design of self-supporting MOF electrocatalyst can substantially improve the NRR performance; ② The effective combination of machine learning, DFT calculation and in situ testing technology has important guiding significance for NRR mechanism study, efficient design and screening of catalysts, etc., which will become the future research trends of NRR catalysis.

Key words: electrochemistry, catalyst, reduction, synthesis, metal organic frameworks

摘要：

室温下电催化氮还原合成氨（nitrogen reduction reaction，NRR）因其较低的能耗而受到广泛关注。到目前为止，设计高效电催化剂以提高NRR性能是研究重点。其中，金属有机骨架（metal organic framework，MOF）及衍生材料因其独特的多孔结构和可控成分等优势促进了其在气体捕获、分离和催化中的应用。本文首先讨论NRR的反应机制，然后重点讨论MOF及衍生材料用作NRR电催化剂的研究进展，最后，对MOF基NRR电催化剂的设计策略、存在问题及NRR催化面临挑战进行了总结与展望。此外，文中指出：① 自支撑MOF基电催化剂的合理设计对NRR性能有质的提升；② 机器学习、DFT计算及原位测试技术的有效结合对NRR机理、催化剂的高效设计及筛选等具有重要指导意义。因此这些也将成为NRR催化未来研究趋势。

关键词: 电化学, 催化剂, 还原, 合成, 金属-有机框架

CLC Number:

TQ032.4

GUO Pengju, HE Xiaobo, YIN Fengxiang. Research progress in MOF-based catalysts for electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction to ammonia[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(4): 1797-1810.

郭朋举, 何小波, 银凤翔. 电催化氮还原合成氨MOF基催化剂研究进展[J]. 化工进展, 2023, 42(4): 1797-1810.

Figures/Tables 7

References 69

1	YE Tiannan, PARK S W, LU Yangfan, et al. Vacancy-enabled N₂ activation for ammonia synthesis on an Ni-loaded catalyst[J]. Nature, 2020, 583（7816）: 391-395.
2	YAO Dazhi, TANG Cheng, LI Laiquan, et al. In situ fragmented bismuth nanoparticles for electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction[J]. Advanced Energy Materials, 2020, 10（33）: 2001289.
3	KITANO M, INOUE Y, YAMAZAKI Y, et al. Ammonia synthesis using a stable electride as an electron donor and reversible hydrogen store[J]. Nature Chemistry, 2012, 4（11）: 934-940.
4	SURYANTO B H R, DU H L, WANG Dabin, et al. Challenges and prospects in the catalysis of electroreduction of nitrogen to ammonia[J]. Nature Catalysis, 2019, 2（4）: 290-296.
5	LIU Huimin, WEI Li, LIU Fei, et al. Homogeneous, heterogeneous, and biological catalysts for electrochemical N₂ reduction toward NH₃ under ambient conditions[J]. ACS Catalysis, 2019, 9（6）: 5245-5267.
6	LIU Anmin, YANG Yanan, REN Xuefeng, et al. Current progress of electrocatalysts for ammonia synthesis through electrochemical nitrogen reduction under ambient conditions[J]. ChemSusChem, 2020, 13（15）: 3766-3788.
7	LI Hongda, GU Shaonan, SUN Zijun, et al. The in-built bionic “MoFe cofactor” in Fe-doped two-dimensional MoTe₂ nanosheets for boosting the photocatalytic nitrogen reduction performance[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2020, 8（26）: 13038-13048.
8	CHEN Gaofeng, REN Shiyu, ZHANG Lili, et al. Advances in electrocatalytic N₂ reduction-Strategies to tackle the selectivity challenge[J]. Small Methods, 2018, 3（6）: 1800337.
9	TANG Cheng, ZHENG Yao, JARONIEC M, et al. Electrocatalytic refinery for sustainable production of fuels and chemicals[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2021, 60（36）: 19572-19590.
10	XU Wence, FAN Guilan, CHEN Jialiang, et al. Nanoporous palladium hydride for electrocatalytic N₂ reduction under ambient conditions[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2020, 59（9）: 3511-3516.
11	HU Xuemin, SUN Yuntong, GUO Shiying, et al. Identifying electrocatalytic activity and mechanism of Ce_1/3NbO₃ perovskite for nitrogen reduction to ammonia at ambient conditions[J]. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental, 2021, 280: 119419.
12	LIU Xi’en, DAI Liming. Carbon-based metal-free catalysts[J]. Nature Reviews Materials, 2016, 1（11）: 16064.
13	MISTRY H, VARELA A S, KÜHL S, et al. Nanostructured electrocatalysts with tunable activity and selectivity[J]. Nature Reviews Materials, 2016, 1: 16009.
14	YANG Xiaofeng, WANG Aiqin, QIAO Botao, et al. Single-atom catalysts: A new frontier in heterogeneous catalysis[J]. Accounts of Chemical Research, 2013, 46（8）: 1740-1748.
15	XUE Yuqi, ZHENG Shasha, XUE Huaiguo, et al. Metal-organic framework composites and their electrochemical applications[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2019, 7（13）: 7301-7327.
16	LIU Juan, HOU Shujin, LI Weijin, et al. Recent approaches to design electrocatalysts based on metal-organic frameworks and their derivatives[J]. Chemistry: an Asian Journal, 2019, 14（20）: 3474-3501.
17	CHEN Jiangyue, CHENG Hui, DING Liangxin, et al. Competing hydrogen evolution reaction: A challenge in electrocatalytic nitrogen fixation[J]. Materials Chemistry Frontiers, 2021, 5（16）: 5954-5969.
18	WANG Jing, LIU Yaping, ZHANG Hu, et al. Ambient electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction on a MoO₂/graphene hybrid: Experimental and DFT studies[J]. Catalysis Science & Technology, 2019, 9（16）: 4248-4254.
19	MURMU S, PAUL S, KAPSE S, et al. Unveiling the genesis of the high catalytic activity in nickel phthalocyanine for electrochemical ammonia synthesis[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2021, 9（25）: 14477-14484.
20	JIAO Dongxu, LIU Yuejie, CAI Qinghai, et al. Coordination tunes the activity and selectivity of the nitrogen reduction reaction on single-atom iron catalysts: A computational study[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2021, 9（2）: 1240-1251.
21	LAN Jiao, LUO Min, HAN Jiuhui, et al. Nanoporous B¹³C₂ towards highly efficient electrochemical nitrogen fixation[J]. Small, 2021, 17（39）: 2102814.
22	YI Xuerui, HE Xiaobo, YIN Fengxiang, et al. NH₂-MIL-88B-Fe for electrocatalytic N₂ fixation to NH₃ with high Faradaic efficiency under ambient conditions in neutral electrolyte[J]. Journal of Materials Science, 2020, 55（26）: 12041-12052.
23	LIU Peixin, JING Peng, XU Xuan, et al. Structural reconstruction of Ce-MOF with active sites for efficient electrocatalytic N₂ reduction[J]. ACS Applied Energy Materials, 2021, 4（11）: 12128-12136.
24	HE Xiaobo, YIN Fengxiang, YI Xuerui, et al. Defective UiO-66-NH₂ functionalized with stable superoxide radicals toward electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction with high faradaic efficiency[J]. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2022, 14（23）: 26571-26586.
25	ZHAO Xinran, YIN Fengxiang, LIU Ning, et al. Highly efficient metal-organic-framework catalysts for electrochemical synthesis of ammonia from N₂ （air） and water at low temperature and ambient pressure[J]. Journal of Materials Science, 2017, 52（17）: 10175-10185.
26	CAO Yueming, LI Peipei, WU Tengteng, et al. Electrocatalysis of N₂ to NH₃ by HKUST-1 with high NH₃ yield[J]. Chemistry-an Asian Journal, 2020, 15（8）: 1272-1276.
27	ZHAO Lu, KUANG Xuan, CHEN Cheng, et al. Boosting electrocatalytic nitrogen fixation via energy-efficient anodic oxidation of sodium gluconate[J]. Chemical Communications （Cambridge, England）, 2019, 55（68）: 10170-10173.
28	YI Jundong, SI Duanhui, XIE Ruikuan, et al. Conductive two-dimensional phthalocyanine-based metal-organic framework nanosheets for efficient electroreduction of CO₂ [J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2021, 60（31）: 17108-17114.
29	XIONG Wei, CHENG Xin, WANG Ting, et al. Co₃（hexahydroxytriphenylene）₂: A conductive metal-organic framework for ambient electrocatalytic N₂ reduction to NH₃ [J]. Nano Research, 2020, 13（4）: 1008-1012.
30	LIU Xin, WANG Zhongxu, ZHAO Jia, et al. Two-dimensional π‍-conjugated osmium bis（dithiolene） complex （OsC₄S₄） as a promising electrocatalyst for ambient nitrogen reduction to ammonia[J]. Applied Surface Science, 2019, 487: 833-839.
31	LI Laiquan, TANG Cheng, JIN Huanyu, et al. Main-group elements boost electrochemical nitrogen fixation[J]. Chem, 2021, 7（12）: 3232-3255.
32	FU Yang, LI Kangkang, BATMUNKH M, et al. Unsaturated p-metal-based metal-organic frameworks for selective nitrogen reduction under ambient conditions[J]. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2020, 12（40）: 44830-44839.
33	HE Xioaobo, LIAO Yuanxiu, TAN Jiabin, et al. Defective UiO-66 toward boosted electrochemical nitrogen reduction to ammonia[J]. Electrochimica Acta, 2022, 409: 139988.
34	TIAN Di, SONG Na, ZHONG Mengxiao, et al. Bimetallic MOF nanosheets decorated on electrospun nanofibers for high-performance asymmetric supercapacitors[J]. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2020, 12（1）: 1280-1291.
35	ZHOU Yingtang, ABAZARI R, CHEN Jing, et al. Bimetallic metal-organic frameworks and MOF-derived composites: Recent progress on electro- and photoelectrocatalytic applications[J]. Coordination Chemistry Reviews, 2022, 451: 214264.
36	LI Weixin, FANG Wei, WU Chen, et al. Bimetal-MOF nanosheets as efficient bifunctional electrocatalysts for oxygen evolution and nitrogen reduction reaction[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2020, 8（7）: 3658-3666.
37	DUAN Jingjing, SUN Yuntong, CHEN Sheng, et al. A zero-dimensional nickel, iron-metal-organic framework （MOF） for synergistic N₂ electrofixation[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2020, 8（36）: 18810-18815.
38	WANG Zixi, HUANG Jianying, MAO Jiajun, et al. Metal-organic frameworks and their derivatives with graphene composites: Preparation and applications in electrocatalysis and photocatalysis[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2020, 8（6）: 2934-2961.
39	KEMPAHANUMAKKAGARI S, VELLINGIRI K, DEEP A, et al. Metal-organic framework composites as electrocatalysts for electrochemical sensing applications[J]. Coordination Chemistry Reviews, 2018, 357: 105-129.
40	DUAN Jihai, SHAO Dezan, HE Xin, et al. Model MoS₂@ZIF-71 interface acts as a highly active and selective electrocatalyst for catalyzing ammonia synthesis[J]. Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects, 2021, 619: 126529.
41	LV Yang, WANG Yiqi, YANG Miao, et al. Nitrogen reduction through confined electro-catalysis with carbon nanotube inserted metal-organic frameworks[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2021, 9（3）: 1480-1486.
42	XU Wanying, LI Cong, LI Feilong, et al. A hybrid catalyst for efficient electrochemical N₂ fixation formed by decorating amorphous MoS₃ nanosheets with MIL-101（Fe） nanodots[J]. Science China Chemistry, 2022, 65（5）: 885-891.
43	LEE H K, KOH C S L, LEE Y H, et al. Favoring the unfavored: Selective electrochemical nitrogen fixation using a reticular chemistry approach[J]. Science Advances, 2018, 4（3）: eaar3208.
44	LV Xianwei, WANG Lu, WANG Guichang, et al. ZIF-supported AuCu nanoalloy for ammonia electrosynthesis from nitrogen and thin air[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2020, 8（18）: 8868-8874.
45	HE Hongming, ZHU Qianqian, YAN Ying, et al. Metal-organic framework supported Au nanoparticles with organosilicone coating for high-efficiency electrocatalytic N₂ reduction to NH₃ [J]. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental, 2022, 302: 120840.
46	SIM H Y F, CHEN J R T, KOH C S L, et al. ZIF-iduced d-band modification in a bimetallic nanocatalyst: Achieving over 44 % efficiency in the ambient nitrogen reduction reaction[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2020, 59（39）: 16997-17003.
47	YANG Yijie, WANG Shuqi, WEN Haoming, et al. Nanoporous gold embedded ZIF composite for enhanced electrochemical nitrogen fixation[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2019, 58（43）: 15362-15366.
48	YIN Fengxiang, LIN Xin, HE Xiaobo, et al. High Faraday efficiency for electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction on Co@N-doped carbon derived from a metal-organic framework under ambient conditions[J]. Materials Letters, 2019, 248: 109-113.
49	LIU Anmin, LIANG Xingyou, YANG Qiyue, et al. Metal-organic-framework-derived cobalt-doped carbon material for electrochemical ammonia synthesis under ambient conditions[J]. ChemElectroChem, 2020, 7（24）: 4900-4905.
50	WANG Fengyi, ZHANG Longcheng, WANG Ting, et al. In situ derived Bi nanoparticles confined in carbon rods as an efficient electrocatalyst for ambient N₂ reduction to NH₃ [J]. Inorganic Chemistry, 2021, 60（10）: 7584-7589.
51	WEN Lulu, LI Xinyang, ZHANG Rui, et al. Oxygen vacancy engineering of MOF-derived Zn-doped Co₃O₄ nanopolyhedrons for enhanced electrochemical nitrogen fixation[J]. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2021, 13（12）: 14181-14188.
52	LUO Shijian, LI Xiaoman, ZHANG Baohai, et al. MOF-derived Co₃O₄@NC with core-shell structures for N₂ electrochemical reduction under ambient conditions[J]. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2019, 11（30）: 26891-26897.
53	MA Chaoqun, LIU Da, ZHANG Yanli, et al. MOF-derived Fe₂O₃@MoS₂: An efficient electrocatalyst for ammonia synthesis under mild conditions[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2022, 430: 132694.
54	WANG Xinming, FENG Zemin, XIAO Boxin, et al. Polyoxometalate-based metal-organic framework-derived bimetallic hybrid materials for upgraded electrochemical reduction of nitrogen[J]. Green Chemistry, 2020, 22（18）: 6157-6169.
55	ZHANG Yizhen, HU Jue, ZHANG Chengxu, et al. Bimetallic Mo-Co nanoparticles anchored on nitrogen-doped carbon for enhanced electrochemical nitrogen fixation[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2020, 8（18）: 9091-9098.
56	CONG Linchuan, YAO Kaida, ZHANG Siqi, et al. Facile synthesis of bimetallic N-doped carbon hybrid material for electrochemical nitrogen reduction[J]. Journal of Energy Chemistry, 2021, 59: 715-720.
57	GUO Wenhan, LIANG Zibin, ZHAO Junliang, et al. Hierarchical cobalt phosphide hollow nanocages toward electrocatalytic ammonia synthesis under ambient pressure and room temperature[J]. Small Methods, 2018, 2（12）: 1800204.
58	CHEN Silong, JANG H, WANG Jia, et al. Bimetallic metal-organic framework-derived MoFe-PC microspheres for electrocatalytic ammonia synthesis under ambient conditions[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2020, 8（4）: 2099-2104.
59	GENG Zhigang, LIU Yan, KONG Xiangdong, et al. Achieving a record-high yield rate of 120.9 for N₂ electrochemical reduction over Ru single-atom catalysts[J]. Advanced Materials, 2018, 30（40）: 1803498.
60	MUKHERJEE S, YANG Xiaoxuan, SHAN Weitao, et al. Atomically dispersed single Ni site catalysts for nitrogen reduction toward electrochemical ammonia synthesis using N₂ and H₂O[J]. Small Methods, 2020, 4（6）: 1900821.
61	Fang LYU, ZHAO Shunzheng, GUO Ruijie, et al. Nitrogen-coordinated single Fe sites for efficient electrocatalytic N₂ fixation in neutral media[J]. Nano Energy, 2019, 61: 420-427.
62	GAO Yunnan, HAN Zishan, HONG Song, et al. ZIF-67-derived cobalt/nitrogen-doped carbon composites for efficient electrocatalytic N₂ reduction[J]. ACS Applied Energy Materials, 2019, 2（8）: 6071-6077.
63	TAO Hengcong, CHOI C, DING Liangxin, et al. Nitrogen fixation by Ru single-atom electrocatalytic reduction[J]. Chem, 2019, 5（1）: 204-214.
64	ZHANG Rui, JIAO Long, YANG Weijie, et al. Single-atom catalysts templated by metal-organic frameworks for electrochemical nitrogen reduction[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2019, 7（46）: 26371-26377.
65	LIU Yanming, SU Yan, QUAN Xie, et al. Facile ammonia synthesis from electrocatalytic N₂ reduction under ambient conditions on N-doped porous carbon[J]. ACS Catalysis, 2018, 8（2）: 1186-1191.
66	MUKHERJEE S, CULLEN D A, KARAKALOS S, et al. Metal-organic framework-derived nitrogen-doped highly disordered carbon for electrochemical ammonia synthesis using N₂ and H₂O in alkaline electrolytes[J]. Nano Energy, 2018, 48: 217-226.
67	SONG Pengfei, KANG Li, WANG Hao, et al. Nitrogen （N）, phosphorus （P）-codoped porous carbon as a metal-free electrocatalyst for N₂ reduction under ambient conditions[J]. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2019, 11（13）: 12408-12414.
68	WANG Jin, HUANG Hao, WANG Peng, et al. N, S synergistic effect in hierarchical porous carbon for enhanced NRR performance[J]. Carbon, 2021, 179: 358-364.
69	LI Yang, ZHANG Qi, LI Can, et al. Atomically dispersed metal dimer species with selective catalytic activity for nitrogen electrochemical reduction[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2019, 7（39）: 22242-22247.

催化剂	电解质	氨产率	法拉第效率/%	参考文献
NH₂-MIL-88B-Fe（Fe基MOF）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	1.205×10^-10mol·s^-1·cm^-2	12.45	[22]
Cu@Ce-MOF-2（铜网原位生长Ce-MOF）	0.1mol/L KOH	14.83μg·h^-1·cm^-2	10.81	[23]
Defective UiO-66-NH₂（缺陷型UiO-66-NH₂）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	2.071×10^-10mol·s^-1·cm^-2	85.21	[24]
Fe-MOF（MIL-101-Fe）	2mol/L KOH	2.12×10^-9mol·s^-1·cm^-2	1.43	[25]
HKUST-1（MOF：铜-BTC）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	46.63μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	2.45	[26]
Cu^Ⅱ MOF（碳布自支撑Cu^Ⅱ-MOF催化剂）	1mol/L Na₂SO₄	24.7mg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	11.9	[27]
Co₃HHTP₂（Co₃（六羟基三苯）₂纳米粒子）	0.5mol/L LiClO₄	22.14μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	3.34	[29]
MIL-100-Al（Al基MOF）	0.1mol/L KOH	10.6μg·h^-1·cm^-2·mg_cat^-1	22.6	[32]
UiO-66-HAc（缺陷型UiO-66）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	31.81μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	48.06	[33]
Co₃Fe-MOF（二维双金属MOF纳米片）	0.1mol/L KOH	8.79μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	25.64	[36]
NiFe-MOF（零维双金属MOF）	0.1mol/L NaHCO₃	9.3μg·h^-1mg_cat^-1	11.5	[37]
MoS₂@ZIF-71（ZIF-71封装MoS₂纳米花）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	56.69μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	30.91	[40]
CNT@CAU-17（碳纳米管插入CAU-17）	0.05mol/L H₂SO₄	11.92μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	31.27	[41]
MIL-101（Fe）/MoS₃（纳米片杂化材料）	0.1mol/L HCl	25.7μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	36.71	[42]
Ag-Au@ZIF（ZIF-71封装Ag-Au）	0.2mol/L LiCF₃SO₃	0.623μg·h^-1·cm^-2	18	[43]
AuCu/ZIF-8（AuCu纳米合金负载ZIF-8）	0.1mol/L HCl	63.9μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	14.2	[44]
HT Au@MOF（疏水性MOF自支撑Au）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	49.5μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	60.9	[45]
Pt/Au@ZIF（ZIF-71封装Pt/Au）	0.2mol/L LiCF₃SO₃	161μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	44	[46]
Au@ZIF-8（纳米金嵌入ZIF-8）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	28.7μg·h^-1·cm^-2	44	[47]

催化剂	电解质	氨产率	法拉第效率/%	参考文献
NH₂-MIL-88B-Fe（Fe基MOF）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	1.205×10^-10mol·s^-1·cm^-2	12.45	[22]
Cu@Ce-MOF-2（铜网原位生长Ce-MOF）	0.1mol/L KOH	14.83μg·h^-1·cm^-2	10.81	[23]
Defective UiO-66-NH₂（缺陷型UiO-66-NH₂）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	2.071×10^-10mol·s^-1·cm^-2	85.21	[24]
Fe-MOF（MIL-101-Fe）	2mol/L KOH	2.12×10^-9mol·s^-1·cm^-2	1.43	[25]
HKUST-1（MOF：铜-BTC）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	46.63μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	2.45	[26]
Cu^Ⅱ MOF（碳布自支撑Cu^Ⅱ-MOF催化剂）	1mol/L Na₂SO₄	24.7mg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	11.9	[27]
Co₃HHTP₂（Co₃（六羟基三苯）₂纳米粒子）	0.5mol/L LiClO₄	22.14μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	3.34	[29]
MIL-100-Al（Al基MOF）	0.1mol/L KOH	10.6μg·h^-1·cm^-2·mg_cat^-1	22.6	[32]
UiO-66-HAc（缺陷型UiO-66）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	31.81μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	48.06	[33]
Co₃Fe-MOF（二维双金属MOF纳米片）	0.1mol/L KOH	8.79μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	25.64	[36]
NiFe-MOF（零维双金属MOF）	0.1mol/L NaHCO₃	9.3μg·h^-1mg_cat^-1	11.5	[37]
MoS₂@ZIF-71（ZIF-71封装MoS₂纳米花）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	56.69μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	30.91	[40]
CNT@CAU-17（碳纳米管插入CAU-17）	0.05mol/L H₂SO₄	11.92μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	31.27	[41]
MIL-101（Fe）/MoS₃（纳米片杂化材料）	0.1mol/L HCl	25.7μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	36.71	[42]
Ag-Au@ZIF（ZIF-71封装Ag-Au）	0.2mol/L LiCF₃SO₃	0.623μg·h^-1·cm^-2	18	[43]
AuCu/ZIF-8（AuCu纳米合金负载ZIF-8）	0.1mol/L HCl	63.9μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	14.2	[44]
HT Au@MOF（疏水性MOF自支撑Au）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	49.5μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	60.9	[45]
Pt/Au@ZIF（ZIF-71封装Pt/Au）	0.2mol/L LiCF₃SO₃	161μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	44	[46]
Au@ZIF-8（纳米金嵌入ZIF-8）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	28.7μg·h^-1·cm^-2	44	[47]

催化剂	电解质	氨产率	法拉第效率/%	参考文献
Co@NC（Co纳米粒子负载氮掺杂碳基底）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	1.57×10^-11mol·s^-1·cm^-2	21.79	[48]
Co/C-900（钴掺杂碳复合材料）	0.1mol/L KOH	4.66μmol·h^-1·cm^-2	11.53	[49]
Bi NPs@CRs（原位衍生铋纳米粒子）	0.1mol/L HCl	20.80μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	11.50	[50]
Zn-Co₃O₄（Zn掺杂Co₃O₄纳米多面体）	0.1mol/L HCl	22.71μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	11.9	[51]
Co₃O₄@NCs（氮掺杂碳/Co₃O₄核壳结构）	0.05mol/L H₂SO₄	42.58μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	8.5	[52]
Fe₂O₃@MoS₂（双金属杂化材料）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	112.15μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	8.62	[53]
Fe_1.89 Mo_4.11O₇/FeS₂@C（双金属杂化材料）	0.1mol/L KOH	105.3μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	54.7	[54]
Mo-Co/NC（Mo-Co嵌入氮掺杂碳基底）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	89.8μmol·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	13.5	[55]
CoRu@NC（双金属氮掺杂碳杂化材料）	0.1mol/L KOH	56.82μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	2.02	[56]
CoP HNC（中空磷化钴纳米笼）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	10.78μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	7.36	[57]
MoFe-Pc微球（Pc磷掺杂碳）	0.1mol/L HCl	34.23μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	16.83	[58]
Ru SAc/N-C（Ru单原子催化剂）	0.05mol/L H₂SO₄	120.9μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	29.6	[59]
Ni-N _x -C（Ni单原子催化剂）	0.5mol/L LiClO₄	115μg·h^-1·cm^-2	21.9	[60]
ISAS-Fe/NC（Fe单原子催化剂）	0.1mol/L PBS	62.9μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	18.6	[61]
Co/N-doped C（钴/氮掺杂碳材料）	0.1mol/L KOH	0.4μmol·h^-1·cm^-2	10.1	[62]
Ru@ZrO₂/NC（添加ZrO₂的Ru单原子催化剂）	0.1mol/L HCl	3.665mg·h^-1·mg_Ru^-1	21	[63]
Fe₁-N-C（Fe单原子嵌入氮掺杂碳基底）	0.1mol/L HCl	1.56×10^-11mol·s^-1·cm^-2	4.51	[64]
NPC-750（氮掺杂多孔炭）	0.05mol/L H₂SO₄	23.8μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	1.42	[65]
C-ZIF-1100-1h（氮掺杂纳米多孔炭）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	3.4×10^-6mol·cm^-2·h^-1	10.2	[66]
NP-C-MOF-5（氮、磷共掺杂多孔炭）	0.1mol/L HCl	1.08μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	0.52	[67]
S/N-MPC（硫改性的氮掺杂多孔炭）	0.05mol/L H₂SO₄	45.51μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	25.16	[68]

催化剂	电解质	氨产率	法拉第效率/%	参考文献
Co@NC（Co纳米粒子负载氮掺杂碳基底）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	1.57×10^-11mol·s^-1·cm^-2	21.79	[48]
Co/C-900（钴掺杂碳复合材料）	0.1mol/L KOH	4.66μmol·h^-1·cm^-2	11.53	[49]
Bi NPs@CRs（原位衍生铋纳米粒子）	0.1mol/L HCl	20.80μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	11.50	[50]
Zn-Co₃O₄（Zn掺杂Co₃O₄纳米多面体）	0.1mol/L HCl	22.71μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	11.9	[51]
Co₃O₄@NCs（氮掺杂碳/Co₃O₄核壳结构）	0.05mol/L H₂SO₄	42.58μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	8.5	[52]
Fe₂O₃@MoS₂（双金属杂化材料）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	112.15μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	8.62	[53]
Fe_1.89 Mo_4.11O₇/FeS₂@C（双金属杂化材料）	0.1mol/L KOH	105.3μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	54.7	[54]
Mo-Co/NC（Mo-Co嵌入氮掺杂碳基底）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	89.8μmol·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	13.5	[55]
CoRu@NC（双金属氮掺杂碳杂化材料）	0.1mol/L KOH	56.82μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	2.02	[56]
CoP HNC（中空磷化钴纳米笼）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	10.78μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	7.36	[57]
MoFe-Pc微球（Pc磷掺杂碳）	0.1mol/L HCl	34.23μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	16.83	[58]
Ru SAc/N-C（Ru单原子催化剂）	0.05mol/L H₂SO₄	120.9μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	29.6	[59]
Ni-N _x -C（Ni单原子催化剂）	0.5mol/L LiClO₄	115μg·h^-1·cm^-2	21.9	[60]
ISAS-Fe/NC（Fe单原子催化剂）	0.1mol/L PBS	62.9μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	18.6	[61]
Co/N-doped C（钴/氮掺杂碳材料）	0.1mol/L KOH	0.4μmol·h^-1·cm^-2	10.1	[62]
Ru@ZrO₂/NC（添加ZrO₂的Ru单原子催化剂）	0.1mol/L HCl	3.665mg·h^-1·mg_Ru^-1	21	[63]
Fe₁-N-C（Fe单原子嵌入氮掺杂碳基底）	0.1mol/L HCl	1.56×10^-11mol·s^-1·cm^-2	4.51	[64]
NPC-750（氮掺杂多孔炭）	0.05mol/L H₂SO₄	23.8μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	1.42	[65]
C-ZIF-1100-1h（氮掺杂纳米多孔炭）	0.1mol/L Na₂SO₄	3.4×10^-6mol·cm^-2·h^-1	10.2	[66]
NP-C-MOF-5（氮、磷共掺杂多孔炭）	0.1mol/L HCl	1.08μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	0.52	[67]
S/N-MPC（硫改性的氮掺杂多孔炭）	0.05mol/L H₂SO₄	45.51μg·h^-1·mg_cat^-1	25.16	[68]

[1]	ZHANG Mingyan, LIU Yan, ZHANG Xueting, LIU Yake, LI Congju, ZHANG Xiuling. Research progress of non-noble metal bifunctional catalysts in zinc-air batteries [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(S1): 276-286.
[2]	SHI Yongxing, LIN Gang, SUN Xiaohang, JIANG Weigeng, QIAO Dawei, YAN Binhang. Research progress on active sites in Cu-based catalysts for CO₂ hydrogenation to methanol [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(S1): 287-298.
[3]	XIE Luyao, CHEN Songzhe, WANG Laijun, ZHANG Ping. Platinum-based catalysts for SO₂ depolarized electrolysis [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(S1): 299-309.
[4]	YANG Xiazhen, PENG Yifan, LIU Huazhang, HUO Chao. Regulation of active phase of fused iron catalyst and its catalytic performance of Fischer-Tropsch synthesis [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(S1): 310-318.
[5]	HU Xi, WANG Mingshan, LI Enzhi, HUANG Siming, CHEN Junchen, GUO Bingshu, YU Bo, MA Zhiyuan, LI Xing. Research progress on preparation and sodium storage properties of tungsten disulfide composites [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(S1): 344-355.
[6]	ZHANG Jie, BAI Zhongbo, FENG Baoxin, PENG Xiaolin, REN Weiwei, ZHANG Jingli, LIU Eryong. Effect of PEG and its compound additives on post-treatment of electrolytic copper foils [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(S1): 374-381.
[7]	ZHAO Wei, ZHAO Deyin, LI Shihan, LIU Hongda, SUN Jin, GUO Yanqiu. Synthesis and application of triazine drag reducing agent for nature gas pipeline [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(S1): 391-399.
[8]	WANG Zhengkun, LI Sifang. Green synthesis of gemini surfactant decyne diol [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(S1): 400-410.
[9]	ZHANG Jie, WANG Fangfang, XIA Zhonglin, ZHAO Guangjin, MA Shuangchen. Current SF₆ emission, emission reduction and future prospects under “carbon peaking and carbon neutrality” [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(S1): 447-460.
[10]	WANG Lele, YANG Wanrong, YAO Yan, LIU Tao, HE Chuan, LIU Xiao, SU Sheng, KONG Fanhai, ZHU Canghai, XIANG Jun. Influence of spent SCR catalyst blending on the characteristics and deNO _x performance for new SCR catalyst [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(S1): 489-497.
[11]	ZHAO Jingchao, TAN Ming. Effect of surfactants on the reduction of industrial saline wastewater by electrodialysis [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(S1): 529-535.
[12]	DENG Liping, SHI Haoyu, LIU Xiaolong, CHEN Yaoji, YAN Jingying. Non-noble metal modified vanadium titanium-based catalyst for NH₃-SCR denitrification simultaneous control VOCs [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(S1): 542-548.
[13]	SHU Bin, CHEN Jianhong, XIONG Jian, WU Qirong, YU Jiangtao, YANG Ping. Necessity analysis of promoting the development of green methanol under the goal of carbon neutrality [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(9): 4471-4478.
[14]	CHENG Tao, CUI Ruili, SONG Junnan, ZHANG Tianqi, ZHANG Yunhe, LIANG Shijie, PU Shi. Analysis of impurity deposition and pressure drop increase mechanisms in residue hydrotreating unit [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(9): 4616-4627.
[15]	WANG Peng, SHI Huibing, ZHAO Deming, FENG Baolin, CHEN Qian, YANG Da. Recent advances on transition metal catalyzed carbonylation of chlorinated compounds [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(9): 4649-4666.