蒸汽动力系统柔性设计和多目标优化研究进展

doi:10.16085/j.issn.1000-6613.2017.06.004

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 蒸汽动力系统（SPS）消耗一次能源（煤等），产生蒸汽、电、机械功与冷剂，在过程系统中起着至关重要的作用。设计与优化蒸汽动力系统不但要考虑柔性以应对来自工艺过程内部与外部的变动，而且要考虑系统的经济性，环保性等指标以适应可持续发展。蒸汽动力系统的柔性与多准则设计已成为过程集成研究的热点。本文首先总结了蒸汽动力系统设计的启发式方法（即经验法）、热力学目标法、数学规划法或将它们相互结合的组合方法的研究进展；进一步对确定条件和不确定条件下的蒸汽动力系统柔性设计的研究情况进行了分析；最后对近十年来考虑经济、环境、有效能等目标、考虑余热发电和可再生能源驱动蒸汽动力系统的多目标优化设计进行了重点综述。研究表明，多种能源驱动的、柔性的、多目标的蒸汽动力系统与工艺过程、换热网络的同步综合是今后研究的重点方向。

关键词: 过程系统, 集成, 蒸汽动力系统, 柔性设计, 多目标优化

Abstract: Stream power system(SPS),which consumes the primary energy(coal etc.) to generate stream,electricity,mechanical power and the refrigerant,plays a vital role in process system. Design and optimization of SPS should not only consider the flexibility to deal with the process from internal and external changes,but also to weigh the system of economic,environmental and other indicators to adapt to sustainable development. The flexibility and multi-criteria design of SPS have become the focus of process integration research. Initially,in this paper the research progress of design and optimization methods of SPS,heuristic method(i.e.,the experience method),the thermodynamic target method,the mathematical programming method or the combination of them for example,were summarized. Moreover,the research situation of the flexible design of the SPS under the condition of certainty and uncertainty were analyzed. Finally,in past 10 years,multi-objective optimization design of SPS considering the economic,environmental,exergetic and other objectives and the cogeneration and rene wable energy driven SPS were emphasized. Research showed that it is the focus of future that simultaneous synthesis of SPS with chemical processes and heat exchanger network consider a variety of energy driven,flexibility,multi-objective optimization.

Key words: process system, integration, stream power network, flexible design, multi-objective optimization

中图分类号:

TQ021.8

李帅, 姜晓滨, 贺高红, 肖武, 吕俊锋, 史朝霞, 罗立. 蒸汽动力系统柔性设计和多目标优化研究进展[J]. 化工进展, 2017, 36(06): 1989-1996.

LI Shuai, JIANG Xiaobin, HE Gaohong, XIAO Wu, LÜ Junfeng, SHI Zhaoxia, LUO Li. Research progress for flexible design and multi-objective optimization of steam power network[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2017, 36(06): 1989-1996.

参考文献

[1] Chen H J,Goswami D Y,Elias K S. A review of thermodynamic cycles and working fluids for the conversion of low-grade heat [J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,2010,14:3059-3067.
[2] 罗向龙,华贲. 蒸汽动力系统设计与综合优化研究综述[J]. 化工学报,2009,60(10):2411-2419. LUO X L,HUA B. A review on design and optimization of steam power system[J]. CIESC Journal,2009,60(10):2411-2419.
[3] BADR O,CALLAGHAN P W O,PROBERT S D. Thermodynamic and thermo-physical properties of organic working fluids for Rankine-cycle engines[J]. Applied Energy,1985,19:1-40.
[4] LINNHOFF B,TOWNSEND D W,BOLAND D,et al. User guide on process integration for the efficient use of energy[J]. Computer & Chemistry Engineering,1982,18:456-462.
[5] Nishio M,Itoh J,UMEDA T,et al. A thermodynamic approach to steam power system design [J]. Industrial Engineering Chemistry Process Design and Development,1982,21(4):640-646.
[6] Chou C C,Shih Y S. A thermodynamic approach to the design and synthesis of plant utility systems[J]. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research,1987,26:1100-1108.
[7] DHOLE V R,LINNHOFF B. Total site targets for fuel,co-generation,emissions and cooling[J]. Computer & Chemistry Engineering,1993,17:101-109.
[8] MARECHAL F,KALITVENTZEFF B. Identification of the optimal pressure levels in steam networks using integrated combined heat and power method [J]. Chemical Engineering Science,1997,52(17):2977-2989.
[9] PAPOULIA S A,GROSSMANN I E. A structural optimization approach in process synthesis—Ⅰ:Utility systems [J]. Computer & Chemistry Engineering,1983,19:481-488.
[10] Colmenares T R,Seider W D. Synthesis of utility systems integrated with chemical processes[J]. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research,1989,28:84-93.
[11] BRUNO J C,FERNANDEZ F,CASTELLS F,et al. A rigorous MINLP model for the optimal synthesis and operation of utility plants [J]. Chemistry Engineering Research Design,1998,76(3):246-258.
[12] LIRA-BARRAGAN L F,JOSE M P,El-Halwagi M M,et al. Sustainable integration of tri-generation systems with heat exchanger networks[j]. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research,2014,53:2732-2750.
[13] Faissal A,Bamufleh H,El-Halwagi M M,et al. Optimal design and integration of solar thermal collection,storage,and dispatch with process cogeneration systems[J]. Chemical Engineering Science,2015,136:158-167.
[14] LI J H,FANG J K,ZENG Q,et al. Optimal operation of the integrated electrical and heating systems to accommodate the intermittent renewable sources[J]. Applied Energy,2015,1:1-11.
[15] Goh W S,Yoke K W,Chun K T,et al. Automated targeting model for synthesis of heat exchanger network with utility systems[J]. Applied Energy,2016,162:1272-1281.
[16] LUO X L,HUANG X J,EI-HALWAGI M M,et al. Simultaneous synthesis of utility system and heat exchanger network incorporating steam condensate and boiler feedwater[J]. Energy,2016,113:875-893.
[17] Nath R. Optimum dispatching of plant utility systems:to minimize cost and local NO_x emissions[C]//Proceeding of the 1992 Industrial Power conference,1992.
[18] Iyer R R,GROSSMANN I E. Optimal multi-period operational planning for utility systems [J]. Computer & Chemistry Engineering,1997,21(8):787-800.
[19] Iyer R R,GROSSMANN I E. Synthesis and operational planning of utility systems for multi-period operation [J]. Computer & Chemistry Engineering,1998,22(7/8):979-993.
[20] MAVROMATIS S P,KOKOSSIS A C. Hardware composites:a new conceptual tool for the analysis and optimization of steam turbine networks in chemical process industries. Part I:Principles and construction procedure[J]. Chemical Engineering Science,1998,53(7):1405-1434.
[21] MAVROMATIS S P,KOKOSSIS A C. Hardware composites:a new conceptual tool for the analysis and optimization of steam turbine networks in chemical process industries. PartⅡ:Application to operation and design[J]. Chemical Engineering Science,1998,53(7):1435-1461.
[22] STROUVALIS A M,HECKL I,FRIEDLER F. Customized solvers for the operational planning and scheduling of utility systems [J]. Computers & Chemical Engineering,2000,24:487-493.
[23] STROUVALIS A M,HECKL I,FRIEDLER F. An accelerated branch-and-bound algorithm for assignment problems of utility systems[J]. Computer & Chemistry Engineering,2002,26:617-630.
[24] Shang Z H,Kokossis A C. A transshipment model for the optimization of steam levels of total site utility system for multiperiod operation[J]. Computers & Chemical Engineering,2004,28:1673-1688.
[25] 罗向龙,华贲. 石化企业蒸汽动力系统柔性设计[J].化工学报,2009,60(4):936-944. LUO X L,YUA B. Synthesis and design of flexible steam power system[J]. CIESC Journal,2009,60(4):936-944.
[26] Enrico C,Chicco G R,Pierluigi M,et al. Cogeneration planning under uncertainty. PartⅠ:Multiple time frame approach[J]. Applied Energy,2011,88:1059-1067.
[27] ENRICO C,CHICCO G R,PIERLUIGI M,et al. Cogeneration planning under uncertainty. PartⅡ:Decision theory-based assessment of planning alternatives [J]. Applied Energy,2011,88:1075-1083.
[28] Mitra S,Sun L G,Grossmann I E. Optimal scheduling of industrial combined heat and power plants under time-sensitive electricity prices[J]. Energy,2013,54:194-211.
[29] Andiappan V,Denny K S Ng,Santanu B h. Synthesis of biomass-based tri-generation systems with uncertainties[J]. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research,2014,53:18016-18028.
[30] HALEMANE K P,GROSSMANN I E. Optimal process design under uncertainty[J]. AIChE Journal,1983,29(3):424-433.
[31] Papalexandri K P,Pistikopoulos E N,Kalitventzeff B. Modelling and optimization aspects in energy management and plant operation with variable energy demands-application to industrial problems[J]. Computers &Chemical Engineering,1998,22(9):1319-1333.
[32] AGUILAR O,SMITH R,PERRY S J,et al. Optimizing the design and operation of industrial utility plants subject to variable demands and prices [J]. European Symposium on Computer Aided Process Engineering,2005,17:907-912.
[33] ADARIJO-AKINDELE O,YANG A,CECEJA F,et al. A systems approach for the optimal retrofitting of utility networks under demand and market uncertainties[M]. Handbook of Power SystemsⅠ. Springer Berlin Heidelberg,2010:293-306.
[34] ZHANG H,LI P. Probabilistic analysis for optimal power flow under uncertainty[J]. IET Generation Transmission&Distribution,2010,4(5):553-561.
[35] Velasco-Garcia P,Varbanov p s,Harvey A G,et al. Utility systems operation optimization-based decision making [J]. Applied Thermal Engineering,2011,31(16):96-3205.
[36] KITAMURA S,MORI K,IZUI Y,et al. operation optimization of factory power generation plant considering an uncertainty[J]. Electrical Engineering in Japan,2014,189(2):822-830.
[37] 盖丽梅,孙力,刘畅,等. 基于带补偿随机规划的蒸汽动力系统优化设计[J]. 化工学报,2014,65(11):4510-4515. GAI L M,SUN L,LIU C,et al. Steam power system optimization design based on stochastic programming with recourse[J]. CIESC Journal,2014,65(11):4510-4515.
[38] SUN LI,LIU CHANG. Reliable and flexible steam and power system Design[J]. Applied Thermal Engineering,2015,79:184-191.
[39] 池晓,徐可培,马学荣,等. 基于LINGO对参数不确定蒸汽动力系统的优化运行研究[J]. 节能,2015(1):21-25. CHI X,XU K P,MA X R,et al. Research on optimal operation of uncertain steam power system based on LINGO[J]. Energy Conservation,2015(1):21-25.
[40] NIE S,HUANG C Z,HUANG G H,et al. Planning renewable energy in electric power system for sustainable development under uncertainty—A case study of Beijing [J]. Applied Energy,2016,162:772-786.
[41] Lajos M H,Rocha P,Siddiqui A S. Optimal operation of combined heat and power under uncertainty and risk aversion[J]. Energy and Buildings,2016,110:415-425.
[42] SUN L,GAI L M,SMITH R. Site utility system optimization with operation adjustment under uncertainty[J]. Applied Energy,2017,186:450-456.
[43] Papandreou V,Shang Z G. A multi-criteria optimization approach for the design of sustainable utility systems [J]. Computer & Chemistry Engineering,2008,32:1589-1602.
[44] Sayyaadi H. Multi-objective approach in thermo-environomic optimization of a benchmark cogeneration system [J]. Applied Energy,2009,86:867-879.
[45] CristObal j,Gonzalo G G,Laureano J,et al. Multi-objective optimization of coal-fired electricity production with CO₂ capture [J]. Applied Energy,2012,98:266-272.
[46] Bamufleh h s,Ponce-Ortega J M,El-Halwagi M M. Multi-objective optimization of process cogeneration systems with economic,environmental,and social tradeoffs [J]. Clean Technology Environment Policy,2013,15:185-197.
[47] Luo X L,Hu J H,Zhao J,et al. Multi-objective optimization for the design and synthesis of utility systems with emission abatement technology concerns[J]. Applied Energy,2014,136:1110-1131.
[48] Sandra S,CAMPO I,Echanobe J,et al. Modeling and multi-objective optimization of a complex CHP process[J]. Applied Energy,2016,161:309-319.
[49] 陈骏,周伟国,王海,等. 基于等效电法的钢铁企业蒸汽系统多目标运行优化策略[J]. 化工学报,2016,67(9):3805-3811. CHEN J,ZHOU W G,WANG H,et al. Multi-objective optimal strategy for steam power system in steel industry based on electricity equivalent calculation[J]. CIESC Journal,2016,67(9):3805-3811.
[50] 张鹏飞,赵浩,荣冈,等. 考虑生产成本和环境成本的蒸汽动力系统多目标运行优化[J]. 化工学报,2016,67(3):715-723. ZHANG P F,ZHAO H,RONG G,et al. Multi-objective optimization for steam power system considering production cost and environmental cost[J]. CIESC Journal,2016,67(3):715-723.
[51] BERTRAND F T,LAMBRINOS G,FRANGOUDAKIS A,et al. Low-grade heat conversion into power using organic Rankine cycles—A review of various applications [J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,2011,15:3963-3979.
[52] HIPOLITO-VALENCIA B J,EUSIEL R C,EL-HALWAGI M M,et al. Optimal integration of organic Rankine cycles with industrial processes [J]. Energy Conversion and Management,2013,73:285-302.
[53] Khaljani M,Khoshbakhti S R,BAHLOULI K. Thermodynamic and thermo-economic optimization of an integrated gas turbine and organic Rankine cycle [J]. Energy,2015,93:2136-2145.
[54] POUYAN R M,KHOSHGOFTAR M H,ROSEN M A,et al. New procedure for design and exergo-economic optimization of site utility system considering reliability[J]. Applied Thermal Engineering,2016,94:478-490.
[55] Zineb F,Touil D,Morosuk T. Multi-criteria exergy based optimization of an Organic Rankine Cycle for waste heat recovery in the cement industry[J]. Energy Conversion and Management,2016,112:81-90.
[56] DUKU M H,HAGAN EB G S. A comprehensive review of biomass resources and biofuels potential in Ghana[J]. Renew Sustainable Energy Reviews,2011,15:404-415.
[57] CALIANDRO P,TOCK L,ADRIANO V E. Thermo-economic optimization of a solid oxide fuel cell–gas turbine system fuelled with gasified lignocellulosic biomass [J]. Energy Conversion and Management,2014,85:764-773.
[58] SERNA M,JOSE M P,EL-HALWAGI M M,et al. Sustainable integration of algal biodiesel production with steam electric power plants for greenhouse gas mitigation[J]. ACS Sustainable Chemistry Engineering,2014,2:1388-1403.
[59] Lira-Barragan L F,JOSE M P El-HALWAGI M M,et al. Reduction of greenhouse gas emissions from steam power plants through optimal integration with algae and cogeneration systems [J]. Clean Technology Environmental Policy,2015,17:2401-2415.
[60] SADEGHI M,CHITSAZ A,ROSEN M A,et al. Thermo-economic optimization using an evolutionary algorithm of a tri-generation system driven by a solid oxide fuel cell [J]. Energy,2015,89:191-204.
[61] Zahra H,Fu P F. Multi-objective based configuration optimization of SOFC-GT cogeneration plant[J]. Applied Thermal Engineering,2017,112:549-559.
[62] 袁建丽,林汝谋,金红光,等. 太阳能热发电系统与分类[J]. 太阳能,2007(5):29-32. YUAN J L,LIN R M,JIN H G,et al. Solar thermal power generation system and classification[J]. Solar Energy,2007(5):29-32.
[63] DELGADO T,GARCIA R. Analysis and optimization of the low-temperature solar organic Rankine cycle [J]. Energy Conversion and Management,2010,51:2846-2856.
[64] Lira-Barragan L F,JOSE M P,EL-HALWAGI M M,et al. Optimal design of process energy systems integrating sustainable considerations[J]. Energy,2014,76:139-160.
[65] WANG M,WANG J F,ZHAO P,et al. Multi-objective optimization of a combined cooling,heating and power system driven by solar energy[J]. Energy Conversion and Management. 2015,89: 289-297.