Transition metal phosphide modification and its applications in electrochemical hydrogen evolution reaction

doi:10.16085/j.issn.1000-6613.2022-1682

Abstract

Abstract:

Transition metal phosphides are efficient catalytic materials for electrochemical hydrogen production because of their high catalytic activity and good stability. However, realizing their large-scale application in electrolytic water hydrogen evolution needs further improvement on the catalytic performance. Based on the composition of transition metal phosphides, their properties were summarized in terms of the metal/phosphorus (M/P) stoichiometric ratio. In addition, the common preparation methods of transition metal phosphides were introduced, and the influence of the modification methods such as element doping, structural defects, interface engineering and coupling of carbon materials, microstructure regulation, and wettability improvement on the electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution were reviewed in detail as well. The development trend of transition metal phosphides is also prospected from the aspects of exploiting new phosphorus source, standardizing electrochemical tests and regulating the crystal planes.

Key words: transition metal phosphides, catalyst, electrolysis, hydrogen production

摘要：

过渡金属磷化物催化活性高、稳定性好，是电催化析氢的良好催化剂。然而，实现过渡金属磷化物在电解水制氢领域的大规模应用，还需要进一步提升其催化性能。本文以过渡金属磷化物的组成变化为出发点，从金属/磷（M/P）化学计量比的角度对过渡金属磷化物的性能进行了总结，介绍了其常见的制备方法，详细综述了元素掺杂、构造缺陷、构建界面工程、耦合炭材料、调控微观结构、改善材料浸润性等改性方法对过渡金属磷化物电催化制氢性能的影响。最后在新型磷源的开发、测试标准化、晶面调控等方面对过渡金属磷化物的发展趋势进行了展望。

关键词: 过渡金属磷化物, 催化剂, 电解, 制氢

CLC Number:

TQ116.21

WANG Yunqing, YANG Guorui, YAN Wei. Transition metal phosphide modification and its applications in electrochemical hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(7): 3532-3549.

王蕴青, 杨国锐, 延卫. 过渡金属磷化物的改性方法及其在电化学析氢中的应用[J]. 化工进展, 2023, 42(7): 3532-3549.

Figures/Tables 16

References 122

1	ZOU Xiaoxin, ZHANG Yu. Noble metal-free hydrogen evolution catalysts for water splitting[J]. Chemical Society Reviews, 2015, 44(15): 5148-5180.
2	HU Congling, ZHANG Lei, GONG Jinlong. Recent progress made in the mechanism comprehension and design of electrocatalysts for alkaline water splitting[J]. Energy & Environmental Science, 2019, 12(9): 2620-2645.
3	LEDENDECKER Marc, KRICK CALDERÓN Sandra, PAPP Christian, et al. The synthesis of nanostructured Ni₅P₄Films and their use as a non-noble bifunctional electrocatalyst for full water splitting[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2015, 54(42): 12361-12365.
4	YAN Ya, XIA Baoyu, ZHAO Bin, et al. A review on noble-metal-free bifunctional heterogeneous catalysts for overall electrochemical water splitting[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2016, 4(45): 17587-17603.
5	KIBSGAARD Jakob, TSAI Charlie, CHAN Karen, et al. Designing an improved transition metal phosphide catalyst for hydrogen evolution using experimental and theoretical trends[J]. Energy & Environmental Science, 2015, 8(10): 3022-3029.
6	SULTAN Siraj, TIWARI Jitendra N, SINGH Aditya Narayan, et al. Single atoms and clusters based nanomaterials for hydrogen evolution, oxygen evolution reactions, and full water splitting[J]. Advanced Energy Materials, 2019, 9(22): 1900624.
7	LI Yingjie, ZHANG Haichuan, JIANG Mingyan, et al. 3D self-supported Fe-doped Ni₂P nanosheet arrays as bifunctional catalysts for overall water splitting[J]. Advanced Functional Materials, 2017, 27(37): 1702513.
8	SHENG Qiang, LI Xiang, ROEL Prins, et al. Understanding the reduction of transition-metal phosphates to transition-metal phosphides by combining temperature-programmed reduction and infrared spectroscopy[J]. Angewandte Chemie (International Ed in English), 2021, 60(20): 11180-11183.
9	PU Zonghua, LIU Tingting, AMIINU Ibrahim Saana, et al. Transition-metal phosphides: Activity origin, energy-related electrocatalysis applications, and synthetic strategies[J]. Advanced Functional Materials, 2020, 30(45): 2004009.
10	LI Xin, ELSHAHAWY Abdelnaby M, GUAN Cao, et al. Metal phosphides and phosphates-based electrodes for electrochemical supercapacitors[J]. Small (Weinheim an Der Bergstrasse, Germany), 2017, 13(39): 1701530.
11	WENG Chenchen, REN Jintao, YUAN Zhongyong. Transition metal phosphide-based materials for efficient electrochemical hydrogen evolution: A critical review[J]. ChemSusChem, 2020, 13(13): 3357-3375.
12	季小好, 王祖民, 陈晓煜, 等. 过渡金属磷化物的制备及电催化析氢性能提升策略[J]. 高等学校化学学报, 2021, 42(5): 1377-1394.
	JI Xiaohao, WANG Zumin, CHEN Xiaoyu, et al. Overview of transition metal phosphide catalysts and hydrogen production by electrolyzed water[J]. Chemical Journal of Chinese Universities, 2021, 42(5): 1377-1394.
13	CARENCO Sophie, PORTEHAULT David, Cédric BOISSIÉRE, et al. Nanoscaled metal borides and phosphides: Recent developments and perspectives[J]. Chemical Reviews, 2013, 113(10): 7981-8065.
14	蒙阳, 杨婵, 彭娟. 基于铁、钴、镍金属磷化物纳米催化剂的碱性条件下电解水制氢的研究进展[J]. 应用化学, 2020, 37(7): 733-745.
	MENG Yang, YANG Chan, PENG Juan. Progress in iron, cobalt and nickel-based metal phosphide nano-catalysts for hydrogen production under alkaline conditions[J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Chemistry, 2020, 37(7): 733-745.
15	WANG Jing, XU Fan, JIN Haiyan, et al. Non-noble metal-based carbon composites in hydrogen evolution reaction: Fundamentals to applications[J]. Advanced Materials (Deerfield Beach, Fla), 2017, 29(14): 1605838.
16	HU Cun, Chao LYU, LIU Shuai, et al. Nickel phosphide electrocatalysts for hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Catalysts, 2020, 10(2): 188.
17	EL-REFAEI S, RUSSO P, SCHULTZ T, et al. Dual doping of MoP with M(Mn, Fe) and S to achieve high hydrogen evolution reaction activity in both acidic and alkaline media[J]. ChemCatChem, 2021, 13(20): 4392-4402.
18	杜迎晨, 雷浩, 钱余海. 电解水制氢技术概述及发展现状[J]. 上海节能, 2021(8): 824-831.
	DU Yingchen, LEI Hao, QIAN Yuhai. Technology overview and development status of hydrogen production from water electrolysis[J]. Shanghai Energy Conservation, 2021(8): 824-831.
19	THEERTHAGIRI Jayaraman, MURTHY Arun Prasad, LEE Seung Jun, et al. Recent progress on synthetic strategies and applications of transition metal phosphides in energy storage and conversion[J]. Ceramics International, 2021, 47(4): 4404-4425.
20	OJHA Kasinath, SAHA Soumen, DAGAR Preeti, et al. Nanocatalysts for hydrogen evolution reactions[J]. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics: PCCP, 2018, 20(10): 6777-6799.
21	SCHIPPER Desmond E, ZHAO Zhenhuan, THIRUMALAI Hari, et al. Effects of catalyst phase on the hydrogen evolution reaction of water splitting: Preparation of phase-pure films of FeP, Fe₂P, and Fe₃P and their relative catalytic activities[J]. Chemistry of Materials, 2018, 30(10): 3588-3598.
22	CALLEJAS Juan F, READ Carlos G, POPCZUN Eric J, et al. Nanostructured Co₂P electrocatalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction and direct comparison with morphologically equivalent CoP[J]. Chemistry of Materials, 2015, 27(10): 3769-3774.
23	Asheli RAY, SULTANA Sabiha, PARAMANIK Lekha, et al. Recent advances in phase, size, and morphology-oriented nanostructured nickel phosphide for overall water splitting[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2020, 8(37): 19196-19245.
24	JIANG Ping, LIU Qian, SUN Xuping. NiP₂ nanosheet arrays supported on carbon cloth: An efficient 3D hydrogen evolution cathode in both acidic and alkaline solutions[J]. Nanoscale, 2014, 6(22): 13440-13445.
25	LI Zuopeng, SHANG Jianpeng, SU Caina, et al. Preparation of amorphous NiP-based catalysts for hydrogen evolution reactions[J]. Journal of Fuel Chemistry and Technology, 2018, 46(4): 473-478.
26	GAO Shiyuan, ZAVABETI Ali, WANG Bin, et al. Nickel phosphides electrodeposited on TiO₂ nanotube arrays as electrocatalysts for hydrogen evolution[J]. ACS Applied Nano Materials, 2021, 4(5): 4542-4551.
27	陈健鑫, 盛楠, 朱春宇, 等. 生物质碳负载镍基纳米颗粒及其电解水析氢性能[J]. 储能科学与技术, 2022, 11(5): 1350-1357.
	CHEN Jianxin, SHENG Nan, ZHU Chunyu, et al. Study on nickel-based nanoparticles supported by biomass carbon for electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution[J]. Energy Storage Science and Technology, 2022, 11(5): 1350-1357.
28	REN Jintao, HU Zhongpan, CHEN Chong, et al. Integrated Ni₂P nanosheet arrays on three-dimensional Ni foam for highly efficient water reduction and oxidation[J]. Journal of Energy Chemistry, 2017, 26(6): 1196-1202.
29	YOU Bo, JIANG Nan, SHENG Meili, et al. Hierarchically porous urchin-like Ni₂P superstructures supported on nickel foam as efficient bifunctional electrocatalysts for overall water splitting[J]. ACS Catalysis, 2016, 6(2): 714-721.
30	ZHANG Wenzhuo, CHEN Guangyi, ZHAO Jian, et al. Self-growth Ni₂P nanosheet arrays with cationic vacancy defects as a highly efficient bifunctional electrocatalyst for overall water splitting[J]. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2020, 561: 638-646.
31	LI Guixiang, WANG Jingang, YU Jiayuan, et al. Ni-Ni₃P nanoparticles embedded into N, P-doped carbon on 3D graphene frameworks via in situ phosphatization of Saccharomycetes with multifunctional electrodes for electrocatalytic hydrogen production and anodic degradation[J]. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental, 2020, 261: 118147.
32	JIN Lihuang, XIA Han, HUANG Zhipeng, et al. Phase separation synthesis of trinickel monophosphide porous hollow nanospheres for efficient hydrogen evolution[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2016, 4(28): 10925-10932.
33	ZHOU Guangyao, MA Yaru, WU Xiaomei, et al. Electronic modulation by N incorporation boosts the electrocatalytic performance of urchin-like Ni₅P₄ hollow microspheres for hydrogen evolution[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2020, 402: 126302.
34	LAI Changgan, LIU Xianbin, DENG Yiqun, et al. Rice-shape nanocrystalline Ni₅P₄: A promising bifunctional electrocatalyst for hydrogen evolution reaction and oxygen evolution reaction[J]. Inorganic Chemistry Communications, 2018, 97: 98-102.
35	Manisha DAS, JENA Nityasagar, PURKAIT Taniya, et al. Single-phase Ni₅P₄-copper foam superhydrophilic and aerophobic core-shell nanostructures for efficient hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2019, 7(41): 23989-23999.
36	WANG Chunde, DING Tao, SUN Yuan, et al. Ni₁₂P₅ nanoparticles decorated on carbon nanotubes with enhanced electrocatalytic and lithium storage properties[J]. Nanoscale, 2015, 7(45): 19241-19249.
37	PAN Yuan, LIU Yanru, ZHAO Jinchong, et al. Monodispersed nickel phosphide nanocrystals with different phases: Synthesis, characterization and electrocatalytic properties for hydrogen evolution[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2015, 3(4): 1656-1665.
38	ZHANG Wenxiu, CUI Liang, LIU Jingquan. Recent advances in cobalt-based electrocatalysts for hydrogen and oxygen evolution reactions[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2020, 821: 153542.
39	REN Yuchun, LI Zerong, DENG Biao, et al. Superior hydrogen evolution electrocatalysis enabled by CoP nanowire array on graphite felt[J]. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2022, 47(6): 3580-3586.
40	GENG Shuo, TIAN Fenyang, LI Menggang, et al. Hole-rich CoP nanosheets with an optimized d-band center for enhancing pH-universal hydrogen evolution electrocatalysis[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2021, 9(13): 8561-8567.
41	LIU Guangbo, WANG Min, XU Yingshuang, et al. Porous CoP/Co₂P heterostructure for efficient hydrogen evolution and application in magnesium/seawater battery[J]. Journal of Power Sources, 2021, 486: 229351.
42	LAI Yue, XIA Wei, LI Jingjing, et al. A confinement strategy for stabilizing two-dimensional carbon/CoP hybrids with enhanced hydrogen evolution[J]. Electrochimica Acta, 2021, 375: 137966.
43	CHEN Teng, MA Jun, CHEN Shanyong, et al. Construction of heterostructured CoP/CN/Ni: Electron redistribution towards effective hydrogen generation and oxygen reduction[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2021, 415: 129031.
44	XU Tingting, YANG Liu, LI Jing, et al. NH₄F-induced morphology control of CoP nanostructures to enhance the hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Inorganic Chemistry, 2021, 60(14): 10781-10790.
45	CHEN Lei, REN Jintao, YUAN Zhongyong. Interface engineering for boosting electrocatalytic performance of CoP-Co₂P polymorphs for all-pH hydrogen evolution reaction and alkaline overall water splitting[J]. Science China Materials, 2022, 65(9): 2433-2444.
46	JEBASLINHEPZYBAI Balasingh Thangadurai, PARTHEEBAN Thamodaran, GAVALI Deepak S, et al. One-pot solvothermal synthesis of Co₂P nanoparticles: An efficient HER and OER electrocatalysts[J]. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2021, 46(42): 21924-21938.
47	XU Siran, ZHAO Haitao, LI Tingshuai, et al. Iron-based phosphides as electrocatalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction: Recent advances and future prospects[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2020, 8(38): 19729-19745.
48	GE Zhenhua, FU Bin, ZHAO Jinping, et al. A review of the electrocatalysts on hydrogen evolution reaction with an emphasis on Fe, Co and Ni-based phosphides[J]. Journal of Materials Science, 2020, 55(29): 14081-14104.
49	PEI Haijiao, ZHANG Limin, ZHI Gang, et al. Rational construction of hierarchical porous FeP nanorod arrays encapsulated in polypyrrole for efficient and durable hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2022, 433: 133643.
50	WANG Yongsheng, WANG Xinyu, ZHANG Lipeng, et al. Insights into the effect of precursors on the FeP-catalyzed hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Inorganic Chemistry, 2022, 61(6): 2954-2961.
51	TIAN Lihong, YAN Xiaodong, CHEN Xiaobo. Electrochemical activity of iron phosphide nanoparticles in hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. ACS Catalysis, 2016, 6(8): 5441-5448.
52	KWONG Wai Ling, Eduardo GRACIA-ESPINO, LEE Cheng Choo, et al. Cationic vacancy defects in iron phosphide: A promising route toward efficient and stable hydrogen evolution by electrochemical water splitting[J]. ChemSusChem, 2017, 10(22): 4544-4551.
53	Cuncai LYU, PENG Zhen, ZHAO Yaoxing, et al. The hierarchical nanowires array of iron phosphide integrated on a carbon fiber paper as an effective electrocatalyst for hydrogen generation[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2016, 4(4): 1454-1460.
54	PARK Yoonsu, KANG Hyeri, HONG Yunkun, et al. Influence of the phosphorus source on iron phosphide nanoparticle synthesis for hydrogen evolution reaction catalysis[J]. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2020, 45(57): 32780-32788.
55	ZHANG Yan, ZHANG Huijuan, FENG Yangyang, et al. Unique Fe₂P nanoparticles enveloped in sandwichlike graphited carbon sheets as excellent hydrogen evolution reaction catalyst and lithium-ion battery anode[J]. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2015, 7(48): 26684-26690.
56	HUANG Huawei, YU Chang, YANG Juan, et al. Ultrasmall diiron phosphide nanodots anchored on graphene sheets with enhanced electrocatalytic activity for hydrogen production via high-efficiency water splitting[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2016, 4(41): 16028-16035.
57	CHOUKI Takwa, MACHREKI Manel, EMIN Saim. Solvothermal synthesis of iron phosphides and their application for efficient electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution[J]. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2020, 45(41): 21473-21482.
58	PRAMANIK Malay, TOMINAKA Satoshi, WANG Zhongli, et al. Mesoporous semimetallic conductors: Structural and electronic properties of cobalt phosphide systems[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2017, 56(43): 13508-13512.
59	Andres PARRA-PUERTO, Kai Ling NG, FAHY Kieran, et al. Supported transition metal phosphides: Activity survey for HER, ORR, OER, and corrosion resistance in acid and alkaline electrolytes[J]. ACS Catalysis, 2019, 9(12): 11515-11529.
60	ZHOU Zheng, PEI Zengxia, WEI Li, et al. Electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution under neutral pH conditions: Current understandings, recent advances, and future prospects[J]. Energy & Environmental Science, 2020, 13(10): 3185-3206.
61	SU Jinzhan, ZHOU Jinglan, WANG Lu, et al. Synthesis and application of transition metal phosphides as electrocatalyst for water splitting[J]. Science Bulletin, 2017, 62(9): 633-644.
62	SHI Yanmei, ZHANG Bin. Recent advances in transition metal phosphide nanomaterials: Synthesis and applications in hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Chemical Society Reviews, 2016, 45(6): 1529-1541.
63	DU Huitong, KONG Rongmei, GUO Xiaoxi, et al. Recent progress in transition metal phosphides with enhanced electrocatalysis for hydrogen evolution[J]. Nanoscale, 2018, 10(46): 21617-21624.
64	CHEN Jiahui, LIU Jianwen, XIE Jinqi, et al. Co-Fe-P nanotubes electrocatalysts derived from metal-organic frameworks for efficient hydrogen evolution reaction under wide pH range[J]. Nano Energy, 2019, 56: 225-233.
65	KUCERNAK Anthony R J, NARANAMMALPURAM SUNDARAM Venkata N. Nickel phosphide: The effect of phosphorus content on hydrogen evolution activity and corrosion resistance in acidic medium[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2014, 2(41): 17435-17445.
66	ZHANG Yanan, LI Lei, CHEN Junlei, et al. MOFs template derived Co/Fe binary phosphide nanocomposite embedded in ternary-doped carbon matrix for efficient water splitting[J]. Ceramics International, 2021, 47(9): 12843-12850.
67	LIN Mengting, LU Ruihu, LUO Wen, et al. Active site identification and interfacial design of a MoP/N-doped carbon catalyst for efficient hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. ACS Applied Energy Materials, 2021, 4(6): 5486-5492.
68	SUN Hongming, YAN Zhenhua, LIU Fangming, et al. Self-supported transition-metal-based electrocatalysts for hydrogen and oxygen evolution[J]. Advanced Materials, 2020, 32(3): 1806326.
69	ZHOU Haiqing, YU Fang, SUN Jingying, et al. Highly active catalyst derived from a 3D foam of Fe(PO₃)₂/Ni₂P for extremely efficient water oxidation[J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2017, 114(22): 5607-5611.
70	HUANG Zhipeng, CHEN Zhongzhong, CHEN Zhibo, et al. Cobalt phosphide nanorods as an efficient electrocatalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Nano Energy, 2014, 9: 373-382.
71	SUN Meng, LIU Huijuan, QU Jiuhui, et al. Earth-rich transition metal phosphide for energy conversion and storage[J]. Advanced Energy Materials, 2016, 6(13): 1600087.
72	王钟, 刘家岐, 刘琛, 等. 过渡金属磷化物用于电解水析氢反应的研究进展[J]. 中国有色金属学报, 2021, 31(11): 3344-3361.
	WANG Zhong, LIU Jiaqi, LIU Chen, et al. Recent progress of transition metal phosphides in hydrogen evolution reaction of electrolyzed water[J]. The Chinese Journal of Nonferrous Metals, 2021, 31(11): 3344-3361.
73	POPCZUN Eric J, READ Carlos G, ROSKE Christopher W, et al. Highly active electrocatalysis of the hydrogen evolution reaction by cobalt phosphide nanoparticles[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2014, 53(21): 5427-5430.
74	JIANG Jun, WANG Chunde, ZHANG Jiajia, et al. Synthesis of FeP₂/C nanohybrids and their performance for hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2015, 3(2): 499-503.
75	EL-REFAEI Sayed M, RUSSO Patrícia A, NICOLA Pinna. Recent advances in multimetal and doped transition-metal phosphides for the hydrogen evolution reaction at different pH values[J]. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2021, 13(19): 22077-22097.
76	LI Yang, DONG Zihao, JIAO Lifang. Multifunctional transition metal-based phosphides in energy-related electrocatalysis[J]. Advanced Energy Materials, 2020, 10(11): 1902104.
77	ROY Sanjib Baran, TRUONG Linh, JEON Jae Ho, et al. Highly desirable platform for efficient hydrogen generation: Electrodeposited CoP on N-doped vertical graphene[J]. ACS Applied Energy Materials, 2021, 4(6): 5697-5705.
78	ZHANG Tianqi, LIU Jian, HUANG Linbo, et al. Microbial-phosphorus-enabled synthesis of phosphide nanocomposites for efficient electrocatalysts[J]. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 2017, 139(32): 11248-11253.
79	ZHANG Chengtian, PU Zonghua, AMIINU Ibrahim Saana, et al. Co₂P quantum dot embedded N,P dual-doped carbon self-supported electrodes with flexible and binder-free properties for efficient hydrogen evolution reactions[J]. Nanoscale, 2018, 10(6): 2902-2907.
80	YU Peng, WANG Fengmei, SHIFA Tofik Ahmed, et al. Earth abundant materials beyond transition metal dichalcogenides: A focus on electrocatalyzing hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Nano Energy, 2019, 58: 244-276.
81	YANG Miao, JIANG Yimin, QU Meijiao, et al. Strong electronic couple engineering of transition metal phosphides-oxides heterostructures as multifunctional electrocatalyst for hydrogen production[J]. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental, 2020, 269: 118803.
82	DANILOVIC N, SUBBARAMAN Ram, STRMCNIK D, et al. Enhancing the alkaline hydrogen evolution reaction activity through the bifunctionality of Ni(OH)₂/metal catalysts[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2012, 51(50): 12495-12498.
83	ZHAO Guoqiang, RUI Kun, DOU Shi xue, et al. Heterostructures for electrochemical hydrogen evolution reaction: A review[J]. Advanced Functional Materials, 2018, 28(43): 1803291.
84	ZHANG Xiangyong, GUO Ting, LIU Tianying, et al. Tungsten phosphide (WP) nanoparticles with tunable crystallinity, W vacancies, and electronic structures for hydrogen production[J]. Electrochimica Acta, 2019, 323: 134798.
85	DUAN Jingjing, CHEN Sheng, ORTÍZ-LEDÓN César A, et al. Phosphorus vacancies that boost electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution by two orders of magnitude[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2020, 59(21): 8181-8186.
86	KUMARAVEL Sangeetha, KARTHICK Kannimuthu, SANKAR Selvasundarasekar SAM, et al. Recent progresses in engineering of Ni and Co based phosphides for effective electrocatalytic water splitting[J]. ChemElectroChem, 2021, 8(24): 4638-4685.
87	WANG Pengcheng, LIU Xuefeng, YAN Yaotian, et al. Exploring CoP core-shell nanosheets by Fe and Zn dual cation doping as efficient electrocatalysts for overall water splitting[J]. Catalysis Science & Technology, 2020, 10(5): 1395-1400.
88	KITCHIN J R, NØRSKOV J K, BARTEAU M A, et al. Modification of the surface electronic and chemical properties of Pt(111) by subsurface 3d transition metals[J]. The Journal of Chemical Physics, 2004, 120(21): 10240-10246.
89	ZHOU Binghui, GAO Ruijie, ZOU Jijun, et al. Surface design strategy of catalysts for water electrolysis[J]. Small (Weinheim an Der Bergstrasse, Germany), 2022, 18(27): e2202336.
90	XIN Hongliang, VOJVODIC Aleksandra, VOSS Johannes, et al. Effects of d-band shape on the surface reactivity of transition-metal alloys[J]. Physical Review B, 2014, 89(11): 115114.
91	Yana MEN, LI Peng, ZHOU Juanhua, et al. Trends in alkaline hydrogen evolution activity on cobalt phosphide electrocatalysts doped with transition metals[J]. Cell Reports Physical Science, 2020, 1(8): 100136.
92	MAN Ho-Wing, TSANG Chui-Shan, LI Molly Meng-Jung, et al. Transition metal-doped nickel phosphide nanoparticles as electro- and photocatalysts for hydrogen generation reactions[J]. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental, 2019, 242: 186-193.
93	SUN Shanfu, ZHOU Xin, CONG Bowen, et al. Tailoring the d-band centers endows (Ni _x Fe_1– _x )₂P nanosheets with efficient oxygen evolution catalysis[J]. ACS Catalysis, 2020, 10(16): 9086-9097.
94	PAN Yuan, SUN Kaian, LIN Yan, et al. Electronic structure and d-band center control engineering over M-doped CoP (M=Ni, Mn, Fe) hollow polyhedron frames for boosting hydrogen production[J]. Nano Energy, 2019, 56: 411-419.
95	CAO Erping, CHEN Zhimin, WU Hao, et al. Boron-induced electronic-structure reformation of CoP nanoparticles drives enhanced pH-universal hydrogen evolution[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2020, 59(10): 4154-4160.
96	WANG Yang, KONG Biao, ZHAO Dongyuan, et al. Strategies for developing transition metal phosphides as heterogeneous electrocatalysts for water splitting[J]. Nano Today, 2017, 15: 26-55.
97	KIBSGAARD Jakob, JARAMILLO Thomas F. Molybdenum phosphosulfide: An active, acid-stable, earth-abundant catalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2014, 53(52): 14433-14437.
98	YAN Xuecheng, JIA Yi, YAO Xiangdong. Defective structures in metal compounds for energy-related electrocatalysis[J]. Small Structures, 2021, 2(2): 2000067.
99	LI Guowei, BLAKE Graeme R, PALSTRA Thomas T M. Vacancies in functional materials for clean energy storage and harvesting: The perfect imperfection[J]. Chemical Society Reviews, 2017, 46(6): 1693-1706.
100	YANG Mengru, WANG Yuanqiang, GU Yanfang, et al. Electro-deposited copper nanoclusters on leaf-shaped cobalt phosphide for boosting hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2022, 902: 163771.
101	YU Yang, QIU Xiaoyu, ZHANG Xinxin, et al. Metal-organic frameworks derived bundled N-doped carbon nanowires confined cobalt phosphide nanocrystals as a robust electrocatalyst for hydrogen production[J]. Electrochimica Acta, 2019, 299: 423-429.
102	ZHANG Xing, YU Xiaolu, ZHANG Linjie, et al. Molybdenum phosphide/carbon nanotube hybrids as pH-universal electrocatalysts for hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Advanced Functional Materials, 2018, 28(16): 1706523.
103	CHUNG Dong Young, Samuel Woojoo JUN, YOON Gabin, et al. Large-scale synthesis of carbon-shell-coated FeP nanoparticles for robust hydrogen evolution reaction electrocatalyst[J]. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 2017, 139(19): 6669-6674.
104	ZHAO Di, SUN Kaian, CHEONG Weng-Chon, et al. Synergistically interactive pyridinic-N-MoP sites: Identified active centers for enhanced hydrogen evolution in alkaline solution[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2020, 59(23): 8982-8990.
105	WANG Minqiang, YE Cui, LIU Heng, et al. Nanosized metal phosphides embedded in nitrogen-doped porous carbon nanofibers for enhanced hydrogen evolution at all pH values[J]. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2018, 57(7): 1963-1967.
106	KIM Dongwon, QIN Xinyu, YAN Bingyi, et al. Nano/microscale integrated mushroom-shaped hydrophilic CoP@Ni-CoP with optimized gas bubble release for high-performance water splitting catalysis[J]. ACS Applied Energy Materials, 2020, 3(10): 9769-9784.
107	WANG Xiang, YANG Linlin, XING Congcong, et al. MOF-derived ultrathin cobalt molybdenum phosphide nanosheets for efficient electrochemical overall water splitting[J]. Nanomaterials (Basel, Switzerland), 2022, 12(7): 1098.
108	ZHANG Wei, HAN Ning, LUO Jiangshui, et al. Critical role of phosphorus in hollow structures cobalt-based phosphides as bifunctional catalysts for water splitting[J]. Small (Weinheim an Der Bergstrasse, Germany), 2022, 18(4): e2103561.
109	WANG Qin, LIU Zhengqing, ZHAO Hongyang, et al. MOF-derived porous Ni₂P nanosheets as novel bifunctional electrocatalysts for the hydrogen and oxygen evolution reactions[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2018, 6(38): 18720-18727.
110	LIU Meijun, YANG Liming, LIU Tian, et al. Fe₂P/reduced graphene oxide/Fe₂P sandwich-structured nanowall arrays: A high-performance non-noble-metal electrocatalyst for hydrogen evolution[J]. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2017, 5(18): 8608-8615.
111	LONG Zhiyun, ZHAO Yuyan, ZHANG Chunhui, et al. A multi-bioinspired dual-gradient electrode for microbubble manipulation toward controllable water splitting[J]. Advanced Materials (Deerfield Beach, Fla), 2020, 32(17): e1908099.
112	YI Xinli, SONG Lizhu, OUYANG Shuxin, et al. Structural and componential engineering of Co₂P&CoP@N-C nanoarrays for energy-efficient hydrogen production from water electrolysis[J]. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2021, 13(47): 56064-56072.
113	CHEN Xibang, SHENG Lang, LI Shuangxiao, et al. Facile syntheses and in situ study on electrocatalytic properties of superaerophobic Co _x P-nanoarray in hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2021, 426: 131029.
114	JIN Song. Are metal chalcogenides, nitrides, and phosphides oxygen evolution catalysts or bifunctional catalysts?[J]. ACS Energy Letters, 2017, 2(8): 1937-1938.
115	LAURSEN Anders B, WEXLER Robert B, WHITAKER Marianna J, et al. Climbing the volcano of electrocatalytic activity while avoiding catalyst corrosion: Ni₃P, a hydrogen evolution electrocatalyst stable in both acid and alkali[J]. ACS Catalysis, 2018, 8(5): 4408-4419.
116	SU Liang, CUI Xiangzhi, HE Ting, et al. Surface reconstruction of cobalt phosphide nanosheets by electrochemical activation for enhanced hydrogen evolution in alkaline solution[J]. Chemical Science, 2018, 10(7): 2019-2024.
117	ZHANG Linlin, DING Xin, CONG Meiyu, et al. Self-adaptive amorphous Co₂P@Co₂P/Co-polyoxometalate/nickel foam as an effective electrode for electrocatalytic water splitting in alkaline electrolyte[J]. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2019, 44(18): 9203-9209.
118	YOU Bo, TANG Michael T, CHARLIE Tsai, et al. Enhancing electrocatalytic water splitting by strain engineering[J]. Advanced Materials (Deerfield Beach, Fla), 2019, 31(17): e1807001.
119	ZHANG Chenyun, XIN Bingwei, XI Zhucong, et al. Phosphonium-based ionic liquid: A new phosphorus source toward microwave-driven synthesis of nickel phosphide for efficient hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, 2018, 6(1): 1468-1477.
120	POPCZUN Eric J, MCKONE James R, READ Carlos G, et al. Nanostructured nickel phosphide as an electrocatalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction[J]. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 2013, 135(25): 9267-9270.
121	杨环环, 喻彬璐, 王佳宏, 等. 二维黑磷的制备、表面功能化与光电催化[J]. 无机盐工业, 2021, 53(5): 13-20.
	YANG Huanhuan, YU Binlu, WANG Jiahong, et al. Preparation, surface functionalization and photoelectrocatalysis of two-dimensional black phosphorus[J]. Inorganic Chemicals Industry, 2021, 53(5): 13-20.
122	曹福臣, 袁振东. 黑磷的发现及其制备和应用发展史[J]. 化学通报, 2021, 84(2): 185-191.
	CAO Fuchen, YUAN Zhendong. The discovery, preparation and application history of black phosphorus[J]. Chemistry, 2021, 84(2): 185-191.

催化剂	电解质	过电位η₁₀/mV	Tafel斜率/mV·dec^-1	电化学稳定性	参考文献
NiP₂ NS/CC	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	75	51	3000CV	[24]
NiP/RGO	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	89（η_起始）	135.1	500CV	[25]
	1mol/L KOH	116（η_起始）	122.4
NiP _x /TNAs	1mol/L KOH	104	70.1	—	[26]
NiP@C	1mol/L KOH	23（η₁₀₀）	12.4	10/20mA/cm²（10h）	[27]
NiP/NF	1mol/L KOH	102	90	1000CV	[28]
Ni₂P/Ni/NF	1mol/L KOH	94	72	10mA/cm²（20h）	[29]
V-Ni₂P/NF	1mol/L KOH	55	48	10mA/cm²（50h）	[30]
Ni-Ni₃P@NPC	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	73	57.93	30/60mA/cm²（25h）	[31]
Ni₃P PHNs	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	85	50	2000CV	[32]
	1mol/L KOH	338（η₂₀）	190
N-Ni₅P₄	1mol/L KOH	96	62.2	1000CV	[33]
Ni₅P₄/NF	1mol/L KOH	64	64	3000CV	[34]
Cuf@Ni₅P₄	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	90	49	10/160mA/cm²（84h）	[35]
Ni₁₂P₅/CNT	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	129	56	1000CV	[36]
Ni₁₂P₅ NCs	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	118	42	500CV	[37]

催化剂	电解质	过电位η₁₀/mV	Tafel斜率/mV·dec^-1	电化学稳定性	参考文献
NiP₂ NS/CC	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	75	51	3000CV	[24]
NiP/RGO	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	89（η_起始）	135.1	500CV	[25]
	1mol/L KOH	116（η_起始）	122.4
NiP _x /TNAs	1mol/L KOH	104	70.1	—	[26]
NiP@C	1mol/L KOH	23（η₁₀₀）	12.4	10/20mA/cm²（10h）	[27]
NiP/NF	1mol/L KOH	102	90	1000CV	[28]
Ni₂P/Ni/NF	1mol/L KOH	94	72	10mA/cm²（20h）	[29]
V-Ni₂P/NF	1mol/L KOH	55	48	10mA/cm²（50h）	[30]
Ni-Ni₃P@NPC	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	73	57.93	30/60mA/cm²（25h）	[31]
Ni₃P PHNs	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	85	50	2000CV	[32]
	1mol/L KOH	338（η₂₀）	190
N-Ni₅P₄	1mol/L KOH	96	62.2	1000CV	[33]
Ni₅P₄/NF	1mol/L KOH	64	64	3000CV	[34]
Cuf@Ni₅P₄	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	90	49	10/160mA/cm²（84h）	[35]
Ni₁₂P₅/CNT	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	129	56	1000CV	[36]
Ni₁₂P₅ NCs	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	118	42	500CV	[37]

催化剂	电解质	过电位η₁₀/mV	Tafel斜率/mV·dec^-1	电化学稳定性	参考文献
CoP/GF	1mol/L KOH	130（η₂₀）	80.1	50h	[39]
CoP	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	84	61	1000CV	[40]
	1mol/L KOH	94	67
CoP/Co₂P	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	87	58	10mA/cm²（24h）	[41]
	1mol/L KOH	133	60
CoP-NC	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	145	55	2000CV	[42]
	1mol/L KOH	167	57
	1mol/L PBS	252	110
CoP/CN/Ni	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	66	39.5	10mA/cm²（12h）	[43]
	1mol/L KOH	106	53.4
CoP	1mol/L KOH	71	60.75	3000CV	[44]
CoP/Co₂P	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	81	36.2	2000CV	[45]
	1mol/L KOH	109	78.9
	1mol/L PBS	227	190.1
Co₂P NF	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	178	32	1000CV	[46]
	1mol/L KOH	190	61

催化剂	电解质	过电位η₁₀/mV	Tafel斜率/mV·dec^-1	电化学稳定性	参考文献
CoP/GF	1mol/L KOH	130（η₂₀）	80.1	50h	[39]
CoP	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	84	61	1000CV	[40]
	1mol/L KOH	94	67
CoP/Co₂P	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	87	58	10mA/cm²（24h）	[41]
	1mol/L KOH	133	60
CoP-NC	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	145	55	2000CV	[42]
	1mol/L KOH	167	57
	1mol/L PBS	252	110
CoP/CN/Ni	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	66	39.5	10mA/cm²（12h）	[43]
	1mol/L KOH	106	53.4
CoP	1mol/L KOH	71	60.75	3000CV	[44]
CoP/Co₂P	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	81	36.2	2000CV	[45]
	1mol/L KOH	109	78.9
	1mol/L PBS	227	190.1
Co₂P NF	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	178	32	1000CV	[46]
	1mol/L KOH	190	61

催化剂	电解质	过电位η₁₀/mV	Tafel斜率/mV·dec^-1	电化学稳定性	参考文献
FeP@PPy/CTs	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	103.1	49.2	46h	[49]
FeP HNPs	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	76	55	10mA/cm²（5h）	[50]
FeP	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	154	65	160mV（6000s）	[51]
Vc-FeP	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	65	49	10mA/cm²（7d）	[52]
	1mol/L KOH	108	62
CFP-FeP HNA	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	45（η₂₀）	53	12h	[53]
	1mol/L KOH	221（η₂₀）	134
FeP NPs	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	76	60	10mA/cm²（12h）	[54]
Fe₂P/GCS	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	88	49	2000CV	[55]
Fe₂P-ND/FG	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	91	47	4000CV	[56]
	1mol/L KOH	168	74
	1mol/L PBS	349	113
Fe₃P	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	49	57	120mV（20h）	[21]
Fe₃P	0.5mol/L H₂SO₄	160	149	5h	[57]