化工园区多米诺事故风险评价与防控技术综述

doi:10.16085/j.issn.1000-6613.2017.04.050

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 定量风险评价是化工厂区或园区预防多米诺效应的主要方法，各类事故预防与控制措施的制定及其有效性检验也依赖于多米诺效应定量风险评价的结果。然而，由于概率风险表征、多米诺场景概率结构、火灾与爆炸致损概率等存在多种不一致或解释不明确的方法模型，使风险评价结果差异性很大，无法更进一步对各类多米诺事故预防与控制技术进行评估。本文首先界定了多米诺效应的基本概念和原理，然后对当前文献中相关多米诺效应定量风险评价方法进行深入剖析，明确了多米诺场景概率以及火灾热辐射、爆炸冲击波、爆炸碎片致损概率的计算方法。另外，还从阈值与安全距离、安全容量及布局优化、安全屏障与防火隔热层、安全与应急管理决策支持、安防与脆弱性分析及灾害衍生事故等方面对多米诺事故防控技术进行了评述。最后，指出以目标设备为核心的各类致损概率计算方法，即设备易损性，是后续研究的关注焦点。

关键词: 多米诺效应, 风险评价, 致损概率, 设备易损性, 安全, 化工园区

Abstract: Quantitative risk assessment of Domino effects(DMQRA) is the key method to be used to prevent Domino accidents in chemical plants or parks. Also,the various pre-control measures and their availability evaluations are based on the result of DMQRA. However,there are many inconsistent or unclear interpreted modes and methods for presentation of probability risk,probability structure of Domino scenarios and damage probabilities of target equipment exposed to fire or blast such that the obtained DMQRA results are in a great variability. Moreover,it is hard to evaluate the specific pre-control measures. In this paper,firstly,the concept and basic principles of Domino effect are clearly defined. Then through carefully analyzing of the various DMQRA methods in literature,the probability structure of Domino scenario and damage probabilities of target equipment attacked by fire thermal radiation,blast wave overpressure and blast fragments are outlined clearly. In addition,damage thresholds,safety distances,safety inventories,layout optimization,safety barriers,thermal insulations,decision supporting for safety and emergency management,security,resilience and natural hazards triggering for domino effect are reviewed in detail. Finally,it is figured out that the advanced methods for calculating of damage probabilities of target equipment exposed to fire,blast and other triggering vectors,i.e. equipment vulnerability,will be focused upon in the future.

Key words: Domino effect, risk assessment, damage probability, equipment vulnerability, safety, Chemical Industry Park

中图分类号:

TQ086
X937

贾梅生, 陈国华, 胡昆. 化工园区多米诺事故风险评价与防控技术综述[J]. 化工进展, 2017, 36(04): 1534-1543.

JIA Meisheng, CHEN Guohua, HU Kun. Review of risk assessment and pre-control of Domino effect in Chemical Industry Park[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2017, 36(04): 1534-1543.

参考文献

[1] KOURNIOTIS S P,KIRANOUDIS C T,MARKATOS N C.Statistical analysis of Domino chemical accidents[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2000,71(1/2/3):239-252.
[2] RONZA A,FÉLEZ S,DARBRA R M,et al.Predicting the frequency of accidents in port areas by developing event trees from historical analysis[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2003,16(6):551-560.
[3] GÓMEZ-MARES M,ZÁRATE L,CASAL J.Jet fires and the Domino effect[J].Fire Safety Journal,2008,43(8):583-588.
[4] DARBRA R M,PALACIOS A,CASAL J.Domino effect in chemical accidents:main features and accident sequences[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2010,183(1/2/3):565-573.
[5] ABDOLHAMIDZADEH B,ABBASI T,RASHTCHIAN D,et al.Domino effect in process-industry accidents——an inventory of past events and identification of some patterns[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2011,24(5):575-593.
[6] CHEN Y T,ZHANG M G,GUO P J,et al.2012 International symposium on safety science and technology:investigation and analysis of historical Domino effects statistic[J].Procedia Engineering,2012:45,152-158.
[7] ZHANG H D,ZHENG X P.Characteristics of hazardous chemical accidents in China:a statistical investigation[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2012,25(4):686-693.
[8] HEMMATIAN B,ABDOLHAMIDZADEH B,DARBRA R M,et al.The significance of Domino effect in chemical accidents[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2014,29:30-38.
[9] HEMMATIAN B,PLANAS E,CASAL J.Fire as a primary event of accident Domino sequences:the case of BLEVE[J].Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2015,139:141-148.
[10] Advisory Committee on Major Hazards.The control of major hazards-first/second/third report[R].London:Healthy and Safety Commission,1976/1979/1984.
[11] MANNAN S.Lees' loss prevention in the process industries:hazard identification,assessment and control[M].3rd ed.Amsterdam:Elsevier,2005.
[12] Center for Chemical Process Safety.Guidelines for chemical process quantitative risk analysis[M].2nd ed.New York:American Institute of Chemical Engineers,2000.
[13] UIJT DE HAAG P A M,ALE B J M.Guideline for quantitative risk assessment——‘purple book’[M].The Hague:Advisory Council on Dangerous Substances,2005.
[14] Seveso-III(Directive 2012/18/EU)[EB/OL].European Parliament and Council,2012.[2016-09-05]. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32012L0018.
[15] 国务院安委会办公室.关于进一步加强化工园区安全管理的指导意见[EB/OL]. 2012.[2016-09-05]. http://www.chinasafety.gov.cn/newpage/Contents/Channel_4976/2012/0809/174959/content_174959.htm. The Work Safety Committee Office of The State Council.Guidance on strengthening the safety management of chemical parks[EB/OL].2012.[2016-09-05].http://www.chinasafety.gov.cn/newpage/Contents/Channel_4976/2012/0809/174959/content_174959.htm.
[16] COZZANI V,GUBINELLI G,ANTONIONI G,et al.The assessment of risk caused by Domino effect in quantitative area risk analysis[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2005,127(1/2/3):14-30.
[17] RENIERS G.An external Domino effects investment approach to improve cross-plant safety within chemical clusters[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2010,177(1/2/3):167-174.
[18] RENIERS G,COZZANI V.Domino effects in the process industries——modelling,prevention and managing[M].Amsterdam:Elsevier,2013.
[19] ALILECHE N,COZZANI V,RENIERS G,et al.Thresholds for Domino effects and safety distances in the process industry:a review of approaches and regulations[J].Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2015,143(s1):74-84.
[20] BAGSTER D F,PITBLADO R M.The estimation of Domino incident frequencies-an approach[J]. Process Safety and Environmental Protection,1991,69(4):195-199.
[21] KHAN F I,ABBASI S A.Models for Domino effect analysis in chemical process industries[J].Process Safety Progress,1998,17(2):107-123.
[22] KHAN F I,ABBASI S A.Studies on the probabilities and likely impacts of chains of accident(Domino effect)in a fertilizer industry[J].Process Safety Progress,2000,19(1):40-56.
[23] KHAN F I,ABBASI S A.An assessment of the likelihood of occurrence,and the damage potential of Domino effect(chain of accidents)in a typical cluster of industries[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2001,14(4):283-306.
[24] COZZANI V,ANTONIONI G,LANDUCCI G,et al.Quantitative assessment of Domino and NaTech scenarios in complex industrial areas[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2014,28(s1):10-22.
[25] ANTONIONI G,SPADONI G,COZZANI V.Application of Domino effect quantitative risk assessment to an extended industrial area[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2009,22(5):614-624.
[26] ABDOLHAMIDZADEH B,ABBASI T,RASHTCHIAN D,et al.A new method for assessing Domino effect in chemical process industry[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2010,182(1/2/3):416-426.
[27] RAD A,ABDOLHAMIDZADEH B,ABBASI T,et al.FREEDOM II:an improved methodology to assess Domino effect frequency using simulation techniques[J].Process Safety and Environmental Protection,2014,92(6):714-722.
[28] KADRI F,CHATELET E,CHEN G P.Method for quantitative assessment of the Domino effect in industrial sites[J].Process Safety and Environmental Protection,2013,91(6):452-462.
[29] 张新梅.化工园区事故多米诺效应风险仿真原理及应用研究[D].广州:华南理工大学,2009. ZHANG X M.Study on simulation principle of accident risk caused by Domino effect and its application in chemical industrial parks[D].Guangzhou:South China University of Technology,2009.
[30] ZHANG X M,CHEN C.Mechanism analysis and risk assessment of escalation scenario in chemical industry zones[J].Process Safety and Environmental Protection,2013,91(1/2):79-85.
[31] BERNECHEA E J,ANTONIO VILCHEZ J,ARNALDOS J.A model for estimating the impact of the Domino effect on accident frequencies in quantitative risk assessments of storage facilities[J].Process Safety and Environmental Protection,2013,91(6):423-437.
[32] KHAKZAD N,KHAN F,AMYOTTE P,et al.Domino effect analysis using Bayesian networks[J].Risk Analysis,2013,33(2):292-306.
[33] KHAKZAD N,KHAN F,AMYOTTE P,et al.Risk management of Domino effects considering dynamic consequence analysis[J].Risk Analysis,2014,34(6):1128-1138.
[34] KHAKZAD N.Application of dynamic Bayesian network to risk analysis of Domino effects in chemical infrastructures[J].Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2015,138:263-272.
[35] ZHOU J F,RENIERS G,KHAKZAD N.Application of event sequence diagram to evaluate emergency response actions during fire-induced Domino effects[J].Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2016,150:202-209.
[36] TUGNOLI A,KHAN F,AMYOTTE P,et al.Safety assessment in plant layout design using indexing approach:implementing inherent safety perspective:Part 1 guideword applicability and method description[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2008,160(1):100-109.
[37] TUGNOLI A,KHAN F,AMYOTTE P,et al.Safety assessment in plant layout design using indexing approach:implementing inherent safety perspective:Part 2-Domino hazard index and case study[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2008,160(1):110-121.
[38] COZZANI V,TUGNOLI A,SALZANO E.The development of an inherent safety approach to the prevention of Domino accidents[J].Accident Analysis & Prevention,2009,41(6):1216-1227.
[39] KHAKZAD N,RENIERS G.Using graph theory to analyze the vulnerability of process plants in the context of cascading effects[J].Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2015,143(s1):63-73.
[40] NI Z J,WANG Y Z,YIN Z G.Relative risk model for assessing Domino effect in chemical process industry[J].Safety Science,2016,87:156-166.
[41] LANDUCCI G,GUBINELLI G,ANTONIONI G,et al.The assessment of the damage probability of storage tanks in Domino events triggered by fire[J].Accident Analysis & Prevention,2009,41(6):1206-1215.
[42] EISENBERG N A,LYNCH C J,BREEDING R J.Vulnerability model:a simulation system for assessing damage resulting from marine spills[R].Springfield:National Technical Information Service,1975.
[43] COZZANI V,SALZANO E.The quantitative assessment of Domino effects caused by overpressure:Part I.probit models[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2004,107(3):67-80.
[44] COZZANI V,SALZANO E.The quantitative assessment of Domino effect caused by overpressure:Part II.case studies[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2004,107(3):81-94.
[45] COZZANI V,SALZANO E.Threshold values for Domino effects caused by blast wave interaction with process equipment[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2004,17(6):437-447.
[46] SALZANO E,COZZANI V.The analysis of Domino accidents triggered by vapor cloud explosions[J].Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2005,90(2/3):271-284.
[47] SALZANO E,COZZANI V.A fuzzy set analysis to estimate loss intensity following blast wave interaction with process equipment[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2006,19(4):343-352.
[48] ZHANG M G,JIANG J C.An improved Probit method for assessment of Domino effect to chemical process equipment caused by overpressure[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2008,158(2/3):280-286.
[49] HAUPTMANNS U.A procedure for analyzing the flight of missiles from explosions of cylindrical vessels[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2001,14(5):395-402.
[50] HAUPTMANNS U.A Monte-Carlo based procedure for treating the flight of missiles from tank explosions[J].Probabilistic Engineering Mechanics,2001,16(4):307-312.
[51] PULA R,KHAN F I,VEITCH B,et al.A model for estimating the probability of missile impact:missiles originating from bursting horizontal cylindrical vessels[J].Process Safety Progress,2007,26(2):129-139.
[52] 张新梅,陈国华.化工罐区爆炸碎片多米诺效应影响概率计算模型[J].化工学报,2008,59(11):2946-2953. ZHANG X M,CHEN G H.Impact probability of Domino effect caused by explosion fragments in chemical tank area[J].CIESC Journal,2008,59(11):2946-2953.
[53] ZHANG X M,CHEN G H.The analysis of Domino effect impact probability triggered by fragments[J].Safety Science,2009,47(7):1026-1032.
[54] MÉBARKI A,NGUYEN Q B,MERCIER F.Structural fragments and explosions in industrial facilities:Part II projectile trajectory and probability of impact[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2009,22(4):417-425.
[55] 钱新明,徐亚博,刘振翼.球罐BLEVE碎片抛射的Monte-Carlo分析[J].化工学报,2009,60(4):1057-1061. QIAN X M,XU Y B,LIU Z Y.Monte-Carlo analysis of fragments projectile from spherical tank BLEVE[J].CIESC Journal,2009,60(4):1057-1061.
[56] 钱新明,徐亚博,刘振翼.球罐BLEVE碎片抛射的危害性研究[J].高压物理学报,2009,23(5):389-394. QIAN X M,XU Y B,LIU Z Y.Research on hazard of fragments from spherical tank BLEVE[J].Chinese Journal of High Pressure Physics,2009,23(5):389-394.
[57] 陈刚,朱霁平,武军,等.爆炸球罐尺寸对抛射碎片击中相邻罐体概率的影响[J].化工学报,2010,61(6):1599-1604. CHEN G,ZHU W P,WU J,et al.Influence of size of bursting spherical tank on impact probability between fragments and adjacent vessels[J].CIESC Journal,2010,61(6):1599-1604.
[58] 陈刚,朱霁平,武军,等.化工储罐间距和体积对爆炸碎片多米诺效应概率的影响[J].火灾科学,2011,20(1):37-42. CHEN G,ZHU W P,WU J,et al.Impact of gap and volume of storage tanks on Domino effect of explosion fragments[J].Fire Safety Science,2011,20(1):37-42.
[59] SUN D L,JIANG J C,ZHANG M G,et al.Parametric approach of the Domino effect for structural fragments[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2012,25(1):114-126.
[60] SUN D L,JIANG J C,ZHANG M G,et al.Influence of the source size on Domino effect risk caused by fragments[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2015,35:211-223.
[61] SUN D L,JIANG J C,ZHANG M G,et al.Investigation of multiple Domino scenarios caused by fragments[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2016,40:591-602.
[62] LISI R,CONSOLO G,MASCHIO G,et al.Estimation of the impact probability in Domino effects due to the projection of fragments[J].Process Safety and Environmental Protection,2015,93:99-110.
[63] GUBINELLI G,ZANELLI S,COZZANI V.A simplified model for the assessment of the impact probability of fragments[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2004,116(3):175-187.
[64] TUGNOLI A,MILAZZO M F,LANDUCCI G,et al.Assessment of the hazard due to fragment projection:a case study[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2014,28(SI):36-46.
[65] GUBINELLI G,COZZANI V.Assessment of missile hazards:evaluation of the fragment number and drag factors[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2009,161(1):439-449.
[66] GUBINELLI G,COZZANI V.Assessment of missile hazards:identification of reference fragmentation patterns[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2009,163(2/3):1008-1018.
[67] MÉBARKI A,MERCIER F,NGUYEN Q B,et al.Structural fragments and explosions in industrial facilities:Part I probabilistic description of the source terms[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2009,22(4):408-416.
[68] 孙东亮,蒋军成,张明广,等.基于最大熵原理的卧罐爆炸碎片数量概率分布[J].化工学报,2011,62(s1):219-224. SUN D L,JIANG J C,ZHANG M G,et al.Probabilistic distribution of fragments number from explosion of horizontal tank based on maximum entropy principle[J].CIESC Journal,2011,62(S1):219-224.
[69] TUGNOLI A,GUBINELLI G,LANDUCCI G,et al.Assessment of fragment projection hazard:probability distributions for the initial direction of fragments[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2014,279:418-427.
[70] NGUYEN Q B,MÉBARKI A,SAADA R A,et al.Integrated probabilistic framework for Domino effect and risk analysis[J].Advances in Engineering Software,2009,40(9):892-901.
[71] 陈刚,朱霁平,武军,等.储罐爆炸抛射碎片对目标储罐的破坏概率研究[J].防灾减灾工程学报,2012,32(2):216-222. CHEN G,ZHU W P,WU J,et al.Damage probability model of target storage tank impacted by explosion fragments[J].Journal of Disaster Prevention and Mitigation Engineering,2012,32(2):216-222.
[72] COZZANI V,GUBINELLI G,SALZANO E.Escalation thresholds in the assessment of Domino accidental events[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2006,129(1/2/3):1-21.
[73] COZZANI V,TUGNOLI A,SALZANO E.Prevention of Domino effect:from active and passive strategies to inherently safer design[J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials,2007,139(2):209-219.
[74] SPOELSTRA M,MAHESH S,KOOI E,et al.Domino effects at LPG and propane storage sites in the Netherlands[J].Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2015,143(s1):85-90.
[75] LEE J Y,LEE J W,KO J W,et al.Optimization for allocating the explosive facilities in order to minimize the Domino effect using nonlinear programming[J].Korean Journal of Chemical Engineering,2005,22(5):649-656.
[76] SO W,KIM Y H,LEE C J,et al.Optimal layout of additional facilities for minimization of Domino effects based on worst-case scenarios[J].Korean Journal of Chemical Engineering,2011,28(3):656-666.
[77] KHAN F I,AMYOTTE P R.Integrated inherent safety index(I2SI):a tool for inherent safety evaluation[J].Process Safety Progress,2004,23(2):136-148.
[78] KHAN F I,AMYOTTE P R.I2SI:a comprehensive quantitative tool for inherent safety and cost evaluation[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2005,18(4/5/6):310-326.
[79] JUNG S H,NG D,DIAZ-OVALLE C,et al.New approach to optimizing the facility sitting and layout for fire and explosion scenarios[J].Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research,2011,50:3928-3937.
[80] LOPEZ-MOLINA A,VAZQUEZ-ROMAN R,MANNAN M S,et al.An approach for Domino effect reduction based on optimal layouts[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2013,26(s1):887-894.
[81] DE LIRA-FLORES J,VAZQUEZ-ROMAN R,LOPEZ-MOLINA A,et al.A MINLP approach for layout designs based on the Domino hazard index[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2014,30:219-227.
[82] BERNECHEA E J,ARNALDOS J.Optimizing the design of storage facilities through the application of ISD and QRA[J].Process Safety and Environmental Protection,2014,92(6):598-615.
[83] KHAKZAD N,RENIERS G.Risk-based design of process plants with regard to Domino effects and land use planning[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2015,299:289-297.
[84] Center for Chemical Process Safety.Layer of protection analysis-simplified process risk assessment[M].New York:American Institute of Chemical Engineers,2001.
[85] LANDUCCI G,ARGENTI F,TUGNOLI A,et al.Quantitative assessment of safety barrier performance in the prevention of Domino scenarios triggered by fire[J].Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2015,143(SI):30-43.
[86] JANSSENS J,TALARICO L,RENIERS G,et al.A decision model to allocate protective safety barriers and mitigate Domino effects[J].Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2015,143(s1):44-52.
[87] LANDUCCI G,MOLAG M,REINDERS J,et al.Experimental and analytical investigation of thermal coating effectiveness for 3m³ LPG tanks engulfed by fire[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2009,161(2/3):1182-1192.
[88] LANDUCCI G,MOLAG M,COZZANI V.Modeling the performance of coated LPG tanks engulfed in fires[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2009,172(1):447-456.
[89] PALTRINIERI N,LANDUCCI G,MOLAG M,et al.Risk reduction in road and rail LPG transportation by passive fire protection[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2009,167(1/2/3):332-344.
[90] DI PADOVA A,TUGNOLI A,COZZANI V,et al.Identification of fireproofing zones in Oil & Gas facilities by a risk-based procedure[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2011,191(1/2/3):83-93.
[91] TUGNOLI A,COZZANI V,DI PADOVA A,et al.Mitigation of fire damage and escalation by fireproofing:a risk-based strategy[J].Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2012,105(s1):25-35.
[92] KHAN F I,ABBASI S A.DOMIFFECT(DOMIno eFFECT):user-friendly software for Domino effect analysis[J].Environmental Modelling & Software,1998,13(2):163-177.
[93] COZZANI V,ANTONIONI G,SPADONI G.Quantitative assessment of Domino scenarios by a GIS-based software tool[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2006,19(5):463-477.
[94] RENIERS G L L,DULLAERT W,ALE B J M,et al.The use of current risk analysis tools evaluated towards preventing external Domino accidents[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2005,18(3):119-126.
[95] RENIERS G L L,DULLAERT W,ALE B J M,et al.Developing an external Domino accident prevention framework:Hazwim[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2005,18(3):127-138.
[96] RENIERS G L L,DULLAERT W.DomPrevPlanning^©:user-friendly software for planning Domino effects prevention[J]. Safety Science,2007,45(10):1060-1081.
[97] RENIERS G L L,DULLAERT W.Knock-on accident prevention in a chemical cluster[J].Expert Systems with Applications,2008,34(1):42-49.
[98] RENIERS G,DULLAERT W,SOUDAN K.Domino effects within a chemical cluster:a game-theoretical modeling approach by using Nash-equilibrium[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2009,167(1/2/3):289-293.
[99] RENIERS G,CUYPERS S,PAVLOVA Y.A game-theory based Multi-plant Collaboration Model(MCM)for cross-plant prevention in a chemical cluster[J].Journal of Hazardous Materials,2012,209/210:164-176.
[100] ZHANG X M,CHEN G H.Modeling and algorithm of Domino effect in chemical industrial parks using discrete isolated island method[J].Safety Science,2011,49(3):463-467.
[101] ZHOU J F,RENIERS G.Petri-net based simulation analysis for emergency response to multiple simultaneous large-scale fires[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2016,40:554-562.
[102] RENIERS G L L,DULLAERT W,AUDENAERT A,et al.Managing Domino effect-related security of industrial areas[J].Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2008,21(3):336-343.
[103] RENIERS G L L,AUDENAERT A.Preparing for major terrorist attacks against chemical clusters:intelligently planning protection measures w.r.t. Domino effects[J],Process Safety and Environmental Protection,2014,92(6):583-589.
[104] RENIERS G L L,SOERENSEN K,KHAN F,et al.Resilience of chemical industrial areas through attenuation-based security[J]. Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2014,131:94-101.
[105] LANDUCCI G,RENIERS G,COZZANI V,et al.Vulnerability of industrial facilities to attacks with improvised explosive devices aimed at triggering Domino scenarios[J].Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2015,143(s1):53-62.