Health risk assessment based on bioaccessibility of heavy metals in aged soils

doi:10.16085/j.issn.1000-6613.2016-2172

Abstract

Abstract: The incidences of heavy metals in contaminated soil are emerging a high and multiple periods.Besides,the bioavailability of heavy metals is decreasing with aging time of the soil,and potential environmental risk of their contamination will correspondingly be declining.In vitro methods can effectively indicate the bioavailability of heavy metals,and significantly cut down the conservativeness of health risk assessment results based on the total exposure dose that is the total concentrations of heavy metals.The in vitro methods have been applied to assess the health risk of heavy metals in aged soils,and have been of great concern.In this paper,the bioaccessibility of heavy metals was defined.The test methods were summed up,and the main factors were also quantitatively clarified,which mainly include in vitro parameters,soil physical and chemical properties and characteristics of heavy metals and so on.In addition,the bioaccessibility of heavy metals applied in health risk assessment were discussed.Finally,the summary of current challenges and the prospectof further studies in the field have been raised.The purpose of this article is to provide the theoretical support for contaminated sites in the risk source identification,repair target determination and management countermeasures screening.

Key words: aged soils, heavy metals, in vitro methods, bioaccessibility, health risk assessment

摘要： 目前，土壤重金属污染事件进入高发期和多发期，同时，随着土壤老化时间的延长，重金属的生物有效性不断降低，其潜在污染环境风险也相应地下降。体外胃肠模拟法（in vitro）能有效指示重金属的人体可给量，可显著降低基于总量为暴露剂量的健康风险评估结果的保守性，因而被应用于评估老化土壤中重金属的人体健康风险，且已深受关注。本文定义了重金属的人体可给性、归纳了其测试方法（PBET、SBET和UBM等），并定量阐明了其主要影响因素，主要包括in vitro参数、土壤理化性质和重金属自身的特性等；然后，论述了重金属人体可给性在健康风险评价的应用。最后，对该领域当前存在的问题和今后的研究方向进行了总结和展望，旨在为污染场地风险源识别、修复目标确定及管理对策筛选提供理论支撑。

关键词: 老化土壤, 重金属, 体外胃肠模拟法, 人体可给性, 健康风险评价

CLC Number:

X131

XU Damao, YAN Bo, CHEN Tao, LEI Chang, LI Liang, XIAO Xianming. Health risk assessment based on bioaccessibility of heavy metals in aged soils[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2017, 36(07): 2632-2638.

许大毛, 晏波, 陈涛, 雷畅, 李亮, 肖贤明. 老化土壤中重金属人体可给性及其健康风险评价[J]. 化工进展, 2017, 36(07): 2632-2638.

References

[1] BOLAN N,KUNHIKRISHNAN A,THANGARAJAN R,et al. Remediation of heavy metal(loid)s contaminated soils-to mobilize or to immobilize?[J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials,2014,266(4):141-166.
[2] GAVRILESCU M. Colloid-mediated transport and the fate of contaminants in soils(Chapter 17)in:the role of colloidal systems in environmental protection[M]. Elsevier,2014:397-451.
[3] 姜林,彭超,钟茂生,等. 基于污染场地土壤中重金属人体可给性的健康风险评价[J]. 环境科学研究,2014,27(4):406-414. JIANG L,PENG C,ZHONG M S,et al. Health risk assessment based on bioaccessibility of heavy metals in contaminated sites[J]. Research of Environmental Sciences,2014,27(4):406-414.
[4] 李继宁,侯红,魏源,等. 株洲市农田土壤重金属生物可给性及其人体健康风险评估[J]. 环境科学研究,2013,26(10):1139-1146. LI J N,HOU H,WEI Y,et al. Bioaccessibility and health risk assessment of heavy metals in agricultural soil from Zhuzhou,China[J]. Research of Environmental Sciences,2013,26(10):1139-1146.
[5] 李华,李海龙,朱宇恩,等. 基于人体可给性的重金属污染场地健康风险评价[J]. 地球环境学报,2015(1):60-66. LI H,LI H L,ZHU Y E,et al. Health risk assessment based on bioavailability of heavy metals in contaminated sites[J]. 2015(1):60-66.
[6] SAVEN S,GUILLON E. Aging effect on Zn retention on a calcareous soil:column experiments and synchrotron X-ray micro-spectroscopic investigation[J]. Science Total Environ,2014,487(15):545-556.
[7] 李传飞,李廷轩,张锡洲,等. 外源镉在几种典型农耕土壤中的稳定化特征[J]. 农业环境科学学报,2017,36(1):85-92. LI C F,LI Y X,ZHANG X Z,et al. Stabilization characteristics of cadmium in some typical agricultural soils[J]. Journal of Agro-Environment Science,2017,36(1):85-92.
[8] 刘彬,孙聪,陈世宝,等. 水稻土中外源Cd老化的动力学特征与老化因子[J]. 中国环境科学,2015,35(7):2137-2145. LIU B,SUN C,CHEN S B,et al. Dynamic characteristics and ageing factors of Cd added to paddy soils with various properties[J]. China Environmental Science,2015,35(7):2137-2145.
[9] 郑顺安,郑向群,李晓辰,等. 外源Cr(Ⅲ)在我国22种典型土壤中的老化特征及关键影响因子研究[J]. 环境科学,2013,24(2):698-704. ZHNEG S A,ZHENG X Q,LI X C,et al. Aging process of Cr(Ⅲ) in 22 typical soils of China and influence factors analysis[J]. Environmental Science,2013,24(2):698-704.
[10] AGNIESZKA E L,PETER S,BRIAN J R. Decision-makers' perspectives on the use of bioaccessibility for risk-based regulation of contaminated land[J]. Environ. Intern.,2010,36(4):383-389.
[11] 李继宁,魏源,赵龙,等. 锑矿区土壤重金属生物可给性及人体健康风险评估[J]. 环境工程技术学报,2014(5):412-420. LI J N,WEI Y,ZHAO L,et al. Bioaccessibility and human health risk assessment of heavy metals in soils of antimony mine area[J]. Journal of Environmental Engineering Technology,2014(5):412-420.
[12] 崔岩山,陈晓晨. 土壤中镉的生物可给性及其对人体的健康风险评估[J]. 环境科学,2010,31(2):403-408. CUI Y S,CHEN X X. Bioaccessibility of soil cadmium and its health risk assessment[J]. Envioronmetal Science,2010,31(2):403-408.
[13] RUBY M V,DAVID A,KEMPTON J H,et al. Lead bioavailability dissolution kinetics under simulated gastric conditions[J]. Environmental Science and Technology,1992,26(6):1242-1248.
[14] 郑顺安,王飞,李晓华,等.应用in vitro法评估土壤性质对土壤中Pb的生物可给性的影响[J]. 环境科学研究,2013,26(8):851-857. ZHENG S A,WANG F,LI X H,et al. Application of in vitro digestion approach for estimating lead bioaccessibility in contaminated soils:influence of soil properties[J]. Research of Environmental Sciences,2013,26(8):851-857.
[15] 钟茂生,彭超,姜林,等. 老化土壤中As的人体可给性控制因素及健康风险[J]. 环境科学研究,2015,28(2):267-274. ZHONG M S,PENG C,JIANG L,et al. Factors controlling arsenic bioaccessibility in aged soils and corresponding health risks[J]. Research of Environmental Sciences,2015,28(2):267-274.
[16] SAWRTJES F A,Rutgers M,LⅡZEN J P A,et al. State of the art of contaminated site management in the netherlands:policy framework and risk assessment tools[J]. Science of the Total Environment,2012,427:1-10.
[17] NG J C,JUHASA A L,SMITH E,et al. Contaminant bioavailability and bioaccessibility:Part 1. A scientific and technical review[R]. Mawson Lakes:Cooperative Research Center of Contamination Assessment and Remediation of Environment,2010.
[18] 刘苗,朱宇恩,李海龙,等. 腐植酸钾对土壤铅化学形态、生物可给性及健康风险的影响[J]. 农业资源与环境学报,2016,33(1):17-22. LIU M,ZHU Y E,LI H L,et al. Effect of potassium humate on chemical fractionation,bioaccessibility and the health risk assessment of lead(Pb)in soil[J]. Journal of Agricultural Resources and Environment,2016,33(1):17-22.
[19] 李仪,章明奎. 三种模拟消化液对土壤重金属的提取性比较[J]. 中国环境科学,2012,32(10):1807-1813. LI Y,ZHANG M K. Comparison of soil heavy metals extraction using three in-vitro digestion tests[J]. China Environmental Science,2012,32(10):1807-1813.
[20] 唐翔宇,朱永官,陈世宝. In vitro法评估铅污染土壤对人体的生物有效性[J]. 环境化学,2003,22(5):503-506. TANG X Y,ZHU Y G,CHEN S B. Assessment of lead bioavailability in contaminated soil using in vitro test[J]. Environmental Chemistry,2003,22(5):503-506.
[21] RUBY M V,SCHOOF R,BRATTIN W,et al. Advances in evaluating the oral bioavailability of inorganics in soil for use in human health risk assessment[J]. Environmental Science and Technology,1999,33(21):3697-3705.
[22] ARTURSSON P,KARLSSON J. Correlation between oral drug absorption in humans and apparent drug pemeability coefficients in human intestinal epithelial(Caco-2)cells[J]. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Comm.,1991,175(3):880-885.
[23] YANG J,MOSBY D E,CASTEEL S W,et al. Lead immobilization using phosphoric acid in a smelter-contaminated soil[J]. Environmental Science and Technology,2001,35(17):3553-3559.
[24] 尹乃毅,都慧丽,张震南,等. 应用SHIME模型研究肠道微生物对土壤中镉、铬、镍生物可给性的影响[J]. 环境科学,2016,37(6):2353-2358. YIN N Y,DU H X,ZHANG Z N,et al. Effects of human gut microbiota on bioaccessibility of soil Cd,Cr and Ni using SHIME model[J]. Environmental Science,2016,37(6):2353-2358.
[25] SEBASTIEN D,JULIEN C,KARINE T,et al. In vivo validation of the unified BARGE method to assess the bioaccessibility of arsenic,antimony,cadmium,and lead in soils[J]. Environmental Science and Technology,2012,46(11):6252-6626.
[26] YANG K,IM J,JEONG S,et al. Determination of human health risk incorporating experimentally derived site-specific bioaccessibility of arsenic at an old abandoned smelter site[J]. Environmental Research,2015,137:78-84.
[27] He K M,WANG S Q,ZHANG J L. Blood lead levels of children and its trend in China[J]. Science of the Total Environment,2009,407(13):3986-3993.
[28] 尹娟,邓超冰,王晓飞,等. 基于农田土壤重金属生物可给性的人体健康风险评价[J]. 江西农业学报,2016,28(12):110-114. YIN J,DENG C B,WANG X F,et al. Assessment of human health risk from heavy metals in farmland soil based on their bioaccessibility[J]. Acta Agriculturae Jiangxi,2016,28(12):110-114.
[29] 崔岩山,陈晓晨,付瑾. 污染土壤中铅、砷的生物可给性研究进展[J]. 生态环境学报,2010(2):480-486. CUI Y S,CHEN X C,FU J. Progress in study of bioaccessibility of lead and arsenic in contaminated soils[J]. Ecology and Environmental Sciences,2010(2):480-486.
[30] LI H B,LI J,ZHU Y G,et al. Comparison of arsenic bioaccessibility in housedust and contaminated soils based on four in vitro assays[J]. Science of the Total Environment,2015,532:803-811.
[31] OOMEN A G,HACK A,MINEKUS M,et al. Comparison of five in vitro digestion models to study the bioaccessibility of soil contaminants[J]. Environmental Science and Technology,2002,36(15):3326-3334.
[32] 付瑾,崔岩山. In vitro系统评价胃肠液pH及土液比对铅、镉、砷生物可给性的影响[J]. 农业环境科学学报,2012,31(2):245-251. FU J,CUI Y S. In vitro model system to evaluate the influence of pH and soil-gastric/intestinal juices ratio on bioaccessibility of Pb,Cd and As in two typical contaminated soils[J]. Journal of Agro-Environment Science,2012,31(2):245-251.
[33] YANG J K,BARNETT M O,JARDINE P M.,et al. Factors controlling the bioaccessibility of arsenic (Ⅴ) and lead (Ⅱ) in soil[J]. Soil & Sediment Contamination,2003,12(2):165-179.
[34] HAMEL S C,ELLICKSON K M,LIOY P J. The estimation of the bioaccessibility of heavy metals in soils using artificial biofluids by two novel methods:mass-balance and soil recapture[J]. Science of the Total Environment,1999,243/244(3):273-283.
[35] YANG J,MOSBY D E,CASTEEL S W,et al. In vitro lead bioaccessibility and phosphate leaching as affected by surface application of phosphoric acid in lead-contaminated soil[J]. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology,2002,43(4):399-405.
[36] JUHASZ A L,SMITH E,WEBER J,et al. In vitro assessment of arsenic bioaccessibility in contaminated (anthropogenic and geogenic) soils[J]. Chemosphere,2007,69(1):69-78.
[37] FINZGAR N,LESTAN D.Relationship of soil properties to fractionation,bioavailability and mobility of lead and zinc in soil[J]. Plant,Soil and Environment,2007,53:225-238.
[38] JACKIE L S,NICHOLAS T B,JITAO S. In vitro gastrointestinal method to estimate relative bioavailable cadmium in contaminated soil[J]. Environmental Science and Technology,2003,37(7):1365-1370.
[39] PALMER S,COX S F,MCKINLEY J M,et al. Soil-geochemicalfactors controlling the distribution and oral bioaccessibility of nickel,vanadium and chromium in soil[J]. Applied Geochemistry,2014,51:255-267.
[40] LIUNG K,OOMEN A,DUITS M,et al. Bioaccessibility of metals in urban playground soils[J]. Journal of Environmental Science and Health,2007,42(9):1241-1250.
[41] 王菲,方凤满. 体外胃肠模拟评估土壤和灰尘中重金属生物可给性研究进展[J]. 卫生研究,2014(4):675-679. WANG F,FANG F M. Research progress in bioaugmentation of heavy metals in soil and dust evaluated by in vitro gastrointestinal simulation[J]. Health Research,2014(4):675-679.
[42] VIOLANT A,PIGNA M.Competitve sorption of arsenate and phosphate on different clay minerals and soils[J]. Soil Science Society of America Journal,2002,66(6):1788-1796.
[43] ROUSSEL H,WATERLOT C,PELFRENE A,et al. Cd,Pb and Zn oral bioaccessibility of urban soils contaminated in the past by atmospheric emissions from two lead and zincs melters[J]. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology,2010,58(4):945-954.
[44] KIM J Y,KIM K W,LEE J U,et al. Assessment of As and heavy metal contamination in the vicinity of duckum Au-Ag mine,Korea[J]. Environmental Geochemistry and Health,2002,24(3):213-225.
[45] POGGIO L,VRŠ? AI B,SCHULIN R,et al. Metals pollution and human bioaccessibility of topsoils in Grugliasco(Italy)[J]. Environmental Pollution,2009,157(2):680-689.
[46] TANG X Y,CUI Y S,DUAN J,et al. Pilot study of temporal variations in lead bioaccessibility and chemical fractionation in some Chinese soils[J]. J. Hazard Mater,2008,160(1):29-36.
[47] 陈晓晨,牛佳,崔岩山. 城市表层土壤中铅的生物可给性及其对人体的健康风险评价——以首钢厂区附近小区域为例[J]. 环境科学,2010(12):3028-3035. CHEN X C,NIU J,CUI Y S. Bioaccessibility of leadin urban top soil and its health risk assessment:a case study of a small area near shougang group[J]. Environmental Science,2010(12):3028-3035.
[48] LIU Y,MA J,YAN H,et al. Bioaccessibility and health risk assessment of arsenic in soil and indoor dust in rural and urban areas of Hubei province,China[J]. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety,2015,126:14-22.
[49] LUO X S,DING J,XU B,et al. Incorporating bioaccessibility into human health risk assessments of heavy metals in urban park soils[J]. Science of the Total Environment,2012,424(4):88-96.
[50] GU Y G,GAO Y P,LIN Q. Contamination,bioaccessibility and human health risk of heavy metals in exposed-lawn soils from 28 urban parks in southern China's largest city,Guangzhou[J]. Applied Geochemistry,2016,67:52-58.
[51] 丁国玉,张斌,万正茂,等. 场地健康风险评估及生物可给性的应用[J]. 环境科学与技术,2014,37(6N):372-376. DING G Y,ZHANG B,WAN Z F,et al. Health risk assessment and application of bioaccessibility[J]. Environmental Science and Technology,2014,37(6N):372-376.