Research status and prospect of water softening technology based on pressure-driven and electro-driven membrane processes

doi:10.16085/j.issn.1000-6613.2021-0826

Abstract

Abstract:

Softening treatment of water is a process to remove calcium, magnesium and other soluble salts in hard water. It is a crucial link in the engineering operation of desalination and salt resource utilization process as well as in the process of drinking water safety guarantee. In this paper, the basic principles of the pressure-driven membrane process represented by salt separation nanofiltration and the electric-driven membrane process represented by selective electrodialysis in water softening were introduced. The research progress of related technologies in water softening process was reviewed. The technical characteristics, advantages and disadvantages of various membrane water softening systems were analyzed in detail. The comparison between salt separation nanofiltration and selective electrodialysis was made, and the possible research directions of membrane water softening technology in the future were prospected.

Key words: water softening, membrane process, nanofiltration, selective electrodialysis, novel electro-driven membrane process

摘要：

水的软化处理是将硬水中的Ca、Mg等可溶性盐除去的过程，是脱盐及盐资源化工序的工程化运行和饮用水安全保障过程中至关重要的一环。本文介绍了以分盐型纳滤为代表的压力驱动膜过程和以选择性电渗析为代表的电驱动膜过程在水软化中的基本原理，综述了相关工艺应用于水软化过程的技术研究进展，详细分析了多种膜法水软化系统的技术特点和优劣势，对分盐型纳滤与选择性电渗析进行了对比，并对未来膜法水软化技术的可能研究方向进行了展望。

关键词: 水软化, 膜过程, 纳滤, 选择性电渗析, 新型电驱动膜过程

CLC Number:

TU991

WANG Jin, CHEN Qingbai, WANG Jianyou, LI Pengfei, DONG Lin. Research status and prospect of water softening technology based on pressure-driven and electro-driven membrane processes[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2022, 41(5): 2649-2661.

王进, 陈青柏, 王建友, 李鹏飞, 董林. 压力驱动及电驱动膜法水软化技术研究现状与展望[J]. 化工进展, 2022, 41(5): 2649-2661.

Figures/Tables 1

References 91

1	张亚峰, 安路阳, 王宇楠, 等. 水中硬度去除方法研究进展[J]. 煤炭加工与综合利用, 2017(12): 54-63.
	ZHANG Yafeng, AN Luyang, WANG Yunan, et al. Research progress of water hardness removal methods[J]. Coal Processing & Comprehensive Utilization, 2017(12): 54-63.
2	蒋展鹏. 环境工程学[M]. 2版. 北京: 高等教育出版社, 2005.
	JIANG Zhanpeng. Environmental engineering[M]. 2nd ed. Beijing: Higher Education Press, 2005.
3	AYOUB G M, ZAYYAT R M, AL-HINDI M. Precipitation softening: a pretreatment process for seawater desalination[J]. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2014, 21(4): 2876-2887.
4	SEPEHR M N, ZARRABI M, KAZEMIAN H, et al. Removal of hardness agents, calcium and magnesium, by natural and alkaline modified pumice stones in single and binary systems[J]. Applied Surface Science, 2013, 274: 295-305.
5	顾凡. 探究不同因素对生活用水水质硬度的影响[J]. 科学技术创新, 2019(27): 37-39.
	GU Fan. To explore the influence of different factors on the hardness of domestic water quality[J]. Scientific and Technological Innovation, 2019(27): 37-39.
6	张浩程. 金沙江某水厂低浊水采用药剂软化法除硬度的试验研究[D]. 重庆: 重庆大学, 2015.
	ZHANG Haocheng. Experimental study on the remove of hardness of low turbidity water of Jinsha river based on pharmacy softening method[D]. Chongqing: Chongqing University, 2015.
7	李陈. 蛭石对钙镁阳离子的吸附性能探讨[D]. 北京: 中国地质大学（北京）, 2009.
	LI Chen. Study of vermiculite adsorbtion to Ca and Mg metal ions[D]. Beijing: China University of Geosciences, 2009.
8	赵志军. 药剂法海水软化研究[D]. 天津: 天津大学, 2008.
	ZHAO Zhijun. Study on seawater softening with chemical reagents[D]. Tianjin: Tianjin University, 2008.
9	徐勇, 陈青柏, 王建友. 离子交换水软化技术研究与应用进展[J]. 化工进展, 2020, 39(S2): 319-328.
	XU Yong, CHEN Qingbai, WANG Jianyou. Research and application progress in the technology of water softening by ion exchange[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2020, 39(S2): 319-328.
10	郑思伟, 栗鸿强, 薛立波, 等. 中国膜产业发展概况及市场分析[J]. 水处理技术, 2021, 47(2): 12-15.
	ZHENG Siwei, LI Hongqiang, XUE Libo, et al. Overview of membrane industry development and market analysis in China[J]. Technology of Water Treatment, 2021, 47(2): 12-15.
11	WANG X L, TSURU T, NAKAO S I, et al. The electrostatic and steric-hindrance model for the transport of charged solutes through nanofiltration membranes[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 1997, 135(1): 19-32.
12	OATLEY D L, LLENAS L, ALJOHANI N H M, et al. Investigation of the dielectric properties of nanofiltration membranes[J]. Desalination, 2013, 315: 100-106.
13	付静怡. 浓海水纳滤分离工艺研究[D]. 天津: 天津科技大学, 2012.
	FU Jingyi. Study on separation processes of concentrated brine by nanofiltration technology[D]. Tianjin: Tianjin University of Science & Technology, 2012.
14	赵颖颖, 王新宇, 李佳乐, 等. 海水体系脱钙与烟气固碳脱硫的集成研究进展[J]. 化工进展, 2020, 39(11): 4315-4329.
	ZHAO Yingying, WANG Xinyu, LI Jiale, et al. Research progress on integration of seawater softening and carbon fixation and desulfurization of flue gas[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2020, 39(11): 4315-4329.
15	SONG Y F, XU J, XU Y, et al. Performance of UF-NF integrated membrane process for seawater softening[J]. Desalination, 2011, 276(1/2/3): 109-116.
16	刘研萍, 王琳, 王进, 等. 膜生物反应器的污染及防治[J]. 工业水处理, 2004, 24(6): 5-9.
	LIU Yanping, WANG Lin, WANG Jin, et al. Fouling mechanisms and prevention in membrane bioreactor[J]. Industrial Water Treatment, 2004, 24(6): 5-9.
17	MANSOURPANAH Y, MADAENI S S, RAHIMPOUR A. Fabrication and development of interfacial polymerized thin-film composite nanofiltration membrane using different surfactants in organic phase; study of morphology and performance[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2009, 343(1/2): 219-228.
18	林亚凯, 汪林, 唐元晖, 等. 中空纤维纳滤膜制备方法的研究进展[J]. 膜科学与技术, 2020, 40(3): 128-135.
	LIN Yakai, WANG Lin, TANG Yuanhui, et al. Research progress in preparation of hollow fiber nanofiltration membranes[J]. Membrane Science and Technology, 2020, 40(3): 128-135.
19	李祥, 张忠国, 任晓晶, 等. 纳滤膜材料研究进展[J]. 化工进展, 2014, 33(5): 1210-1218, 1229.
	LI Xiang, ZHANG Zhongguo, REN Xiaojing, et al. Progress in nanofiltration membrane materials[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2014, 33(5): 1210-1218, 1229.
20	张超, 张杨, 郭敏, 等. 界面聚合法制备复合纳滤膜的缺陷及其改性研究进展[J]. 化工进展, 2012, 31(S2): 167-171.
	ZHANG Chao, ZHANG Yang, GUO Min, et al. Disadvantages of interfacially polymerized nanofiltration composite membranes and modification[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2012, 31(S2): 167-171.
21	高尚哲. 纳滤技术在饮用水处理中的应用及前景分析[J]. 绿色环保建材, 2018(3): 15-16.
	GAO Shangzhe. Application and prospect analysis of nanofiltration technology in drinking water treatment[J]. Green Environmental Protection Building Materials, 2018(3): 15-16.
22	LABBAN O, LIU C, CHONG T H, et al. Fundamentals of low-pressure nanofiltration: Membrane characterization, modeling, and understanding the multi-ionic interactions in water softening[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2017, 521: 18-32.
23	HU D, XU Z L, WEI Y M, et al. Poly(styrene sulfonic acid) sodium modified nanofiltration membranes with improved permeability for the softening of highly concentrated seawater[J]. Desalination, 2014, 336: 179-186.
24	YUAN B B, SUN H H, ZHAO S C, et al. Semi-aromatic polyamide nanofiltration membranes with tuned surface charge and pore size distribution designed for the efficient removal of Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ [J]. Separation and Purification Technology, 2019, 220: 162-175.
25	FANG W X, SHI L, WANG R. Interfacially polymerized composite nanofiltration hollow fiber membranes for low-pressure water softening[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2013, 430: 129-139.
26	李巧云, 贺艳, 徐梦雪, 等. 地质聚合物基无机膜去除水中钙、镁离子的研究[J]. 功能材料, 2017, 48(1): 1215-1220.
	LI Qiaoyun, HE Yan, XU Mengxue, et al. Study on the removal of Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ in water by the geopolymer-based inorganic membrane[J]. Journal of Functional Materials, 2017, 48(1): 1215-1220.
27	李晓明, 王铎, 柴涛, 等. 纳滤海水软化的实验研究[J]. 高校化学工程学报, 2009, 23(4): 582-586.
	LI Xiaoming, WANG Duo, CHAI Tao, et al. Study on seawater softening by nanofiltration membrane[J]. Journal of Chemical Engineering of Chinese Universities, 2009, 23(4): 582-586.
28	袁俊生, 焦亮, 刘杰. 利用纳滤膜软化浓海水研究[J]. 水处理技术, 2012, 38(11): 81-83, 89.
	YUAN Junsheng, JIAO Liang, LIU Jie. Softening of concentrated seawater by nanofiltration membrane[J]. Technology of Water Treatment, 2012, 38(11): 81-83, 89.
29	张莉娜, 黄婕, 熊丹柳, 等. 纳滤膜脱盐及其在海水软化中的应用[J]. 膜科学与技术, 2012, 32(1): 97-101.
	ZHANG Lina, HUANG Jie, XIONG Danliu, et al. Desalination of nanofiltration membranes and its application in seawater softening[J]. Membrane Science and Technology, 2012, 32(1): 97-101.
30	邢锋芝, 穆凤芸, 徐世昌, 等. 海水/工业含盐废水纳滤除硬技术试验研究[J]. 天津化工, 2019, 33(2): 3-8.
	XING Fengzhi, MU Fengyun, XU Shichang, et al. Experimental study on the technology of eliminating hardness of sea water lindustrial salty waste water by nanofiltration[J]. Tianjin Chemical Industry, 2019, 33(2): 3-8.
31	OHNO K, MATSUI Y, ITOH M, et al. NF membrane fouling by aluminum and iron coagulant residuals after coagulation-MF pretreatment[J]. Desalination, 2010, 254(1/2/3): 17-22.
32	戴雨辰, 张显球, 杜明霞, 等. 磁化对纳滤膜通量和软化除盐的影响[J]. 工业水处理, 2017, 37(1): 34-36.
	DAI Yuchen, ZHANG Xianqiu, DU Mingxia, et al. Influences of magnetization on the flux of nanofiltration membrane and softening desalinization[J]. Industrial Water Treatment, 2017, 37(1): 34-36.
33	SU B W, WU T, LI Z C, et al. Pilot study of seawater nanofiltration softening technology based on integrated membrane system[J]. Desalination, 2015, 368: 193-201.
34	WANG Y L, JU L, XU F, et al. Effect of a nanofiltration combined process on the treatment of high-hardness and micropolluted water[J]. Environmental Research, 2020, 182: 109063.
35	LIU J, YUAN J S, JI Z Y, et al. Concentrating brine from seawater desalination process by nanofiltration-electrodialysis integrated membrane technology[J]. Desalination, 2016, 390: 53-61.
36	张泉, 郭曦, 董文艺, 等. 预处理方式对纳滤工艺性能及膜污染影响研究[J]. 膜科学与技术, 2014, 34(1): 82-86, 90.
	ZHANG Quan, GUO Xi, DONG Wenyi, et al. Comparison of pretreatments on nanofiltration performance and membrane fouling[J]. Membrane Science and Technology, 2014, 34(1): 82-86, 90.
37	WANG X Y, MA J X, WANG Z W, et al. Reinvestigation of membrane cleaning mechanisms using NaOCl: role of reagent diffusion[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2018, 550: 278-285.
38	祝海涛, 杨波, 高从堦. 电渗析过程传质模型的研究进展[J]. 化工进展, 2020, 39(3): 815-823.
	ZHU Haitao, YANG Bo, GAO Congjie. Research progress on mass transfer models for electrodialysis process[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2020, 39(3): 815-823.
39	CHEN Q B, JI Z Y, LIU J, et al. Development of recovering lithium from brines by selective-electrodialysis: effect of coexisting cations on the migration of lithium[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2018, 548: 408-420.
40	陈静, 张杰, 金艳, 等. 纳滤和电渗析对浓海水一二价离子的分离性能[J]. 过程工程学报, 2017, 17(3): 491-499.
	CHEN Jing, ZHANG Jie, JIN Yan, et al. Nanofiltration and electrodialysis on separation of monovalent and divalent ions from concentrated seawater[J]. The Chinese Journal of Process Engineering, 2017, 17(3): 491-499.
41	ZHANG Y, PAEPEN S, PINOY L, et al. Selectrodialysis: fractionation of divalent ions from monovalent ions in a novel electrodialysis stack[J]. Separation and Purification Technology, 2012, 88: 191-201.
42	SADRZADEH M, MOHAMMADI T. Sea water desalination using electrodialysis[J]. Desalination, 2008, 221(1/2/3): 440-447.
43	TUREK M. Dual-purpose desalination-salt production electrodialysis[J]. Desalination, 2003, 153(1/2/3): 377-381.
44	FARROKHZAD H, MOGHBELI M R, GERVEN T VAN, et al. Surface modification of composite ion exchange membranes by polyaniline[J]. Reactive and Functional Polymers, 2015, 86: 161-167.
45	GOHIL G S, BINSU V V, SHAHI V K. Preparation and characterization of mono-valent ion selective polypyrrole composite ion-exchange membranes[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2006, 280(1/2): 210-218.
46	LI J, ZHOU M L, LIN J Y, et al. Mono-valent cation selective membranes for electrodialysis by introducing polyquaternium-7 in a commercial cation exchange membrane[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2015, 486: 89-96.
47	HU Y, WANG M, WANG D, et al. Feasibility study on surface modification of cation exchange membranes by quaternized chitosan for improving its selectivity[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2008, 319(1/2): 5-9.
48	LI N W, GUIVER M D. Ion transport by nanochannels in ion-containing aromatic copolymers[J]. Macromolecules, 2014, 47(7): 2175-2198.
49	IRFAN M, XU T T, GE L, et al. Zwitterion structure membrane provides high monovalent/divalent cation electrodialysis selectivity: investigating the effect of functional groups and operating parameters[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2019, 588: 117211.
50	IRFAN M, WANG Y M, XU T W. Novel electrodialysis membranes with hydrophobic alkyl spacers and zwitterion structure enable high monovalent/divalent cation selectivity[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2020, 383: 123171.
51	李健, 徐燕青, 阮慧敏, 等. 单价选择性阳离子交换膜的研究进展[J]. 膜科学与技术, 2015, 35(3): 113-120.
	LI Jian, XU Yanqing, RUAN Huimin, et al. Monovalent cation selective membranes: state and development perspective[J]. Membrane Science and Technology, 2015, 35(3): 113-120.
52	孙小寒, 苏成龙, 王建友. 离子选择性电渗析处理海水淡化浓海水[J]. 水处理技术, 2015, 41(11): 86-91.
	SUN Xiaohan, SU Chenglong, WANG Jianyou. Concentrated seawater treatment by ion-selective electrodialysis[J]. Technology of Water Treatment, 2015, 41(11): 86-91.
53	SOSA-FERNANDEZ P A, POST J W, LEERMAKERS F A M, et al. Removal of divalent ions from viscous polymer-flooding produced water and seawater via electrodialysis[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2019, 589: 117251.
54	ZHANG W, MIAO M J, PAN J F, et al. Separation of divalent ions from seawater concentrate to enhance the purity of coarse salt by electrodialysis with monovalent-selective membranes[J]. Desalination, 2017, 411: 28-37.
55	CHAI P, WANG J Y, LU H X. The cleaner production of monosodium l-glutamate by resin-filled electro-membrane reactor[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2015, 493: 549-556.
56	CHEN Q B, REN H, TIAN Z H, et al. Conversion and pre-concentration of SWRO reject brine into high solubility liquid salts (HSLS) by using electrodialysis metathesis[J]. Separation and Purification Technology, 2019, 213: 587-598.
57	邵刚, 奚凤翔. 频繁倒极电渗析(EDR)及其应用[J]. 环境工程, 1994, 12(2): 49-54.
	SHAO Gang, XI Fengxiang. Frequent reversal electrodialysis (EDR) and its application[J]. Environmental Engineering, 1994, 12(2): 49-54.
58	PILAT B V. Industrial application of electrodialysis reversal systems[J]. Desalination, 2003, 158(1/2/3): 87-89.
59	TUREK M, DYDO P. Electrodialysis reversal of calcium sulphate and calcium carbonate supersaturated solution[J]. Desalination, 2003, 158(1/2/3): 91-94.
60	SONG J H, YEON K H, MOON S H. Effect of current density on ionic transport and water dissociation phenomena in a continuous electrodeionization (CEDI)[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2007, 291(1/2): 165-171.
61	LEE J W, YEON K H, SONG J H, et al. Characterization of electroregeneration and determination of optimal current density in continuous electrodeionization[J]. Desalination, 2007, 207(1/2/3): 276-285.
62	WOOD J, GIFFORD J, ARBA J, et al. Production of ultrapure water by continuous electrodeionization[J]. Desalination, 2010, 250(3): 973-976.
63	DERMENTZIS K. Continuous electrodeionization through electrostatic shielding[J]. Electrochimica Acta, 2008, 53(6): 2953-2962.
64	LEE H J, HONG M K, MOON S H. A feasibility study on water softening by electrodeionization with the periodic polarity change[J]. Desalination, 2012, 284: 221-227.
65	LEE H J, SONG J H, MOON S H. Comparison of electrodialysis reversal(EDR) and electrodeionization reversal(EDIR) for water softening[J]. Desalination, 2013, 314: 43-49.
66	ZHAO Y Y, WANG J H, JI Z Y, et al. A novel technology of carbon dioxide adsorption and mineralization via seawater decalcification by bipolar membrane electrodialysis system with a crystallizer[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2020, 381: 122542.
67	SANJUÁN I, BENAVENTE D, GARCÍA-GARCÍA V, et al. Electrochemical softening of concentrates from an electrodialysis brackish water desalination plant: Efficiency enhancement using a three-dimensional cathode[J]. Separation and Purification Technology, 2019, 208: 217-226.
68	ZEPPENFELD K. Electrochemical removal of calcium and magnesium ions from aqueous solutions[J]. Desalination, 2011, 277(1/2/3): 99-105.
69	ZHI S L, ZHANG K Q. Hardness removal by a novel electrochemical method[J]. Desalination, 2016, 381: 8-14.
70	JIN H C, YU Y, CHEN X M. Membrane-based electrochemical precipitation for water softening[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2020, 597: 117639.
71	PORADA S, ZHAO R, VAN DER WAL A, et al. Review on the science and technology of water desalination by capacitive deionization[J]. Progress in Materials Science, 2013, 58(8): 1388-1442.
72	潘杰峰, 郑瑜, 丁金成, 等. 膜法电容去离子技术用于水溶液中单/多价阴离子的分离[J]. 化工学报, 2018, 69(8): 3502-3508.
	PAN Jiefeng, ZHENG Yu, DING Jincheng, et al. Monovalent anions removal by capacitive deionization integrated with monovalent anion permselective exchange membrane[J]. CIESC Journal, 2018, 69(8): 3502-3508.
73	ZHANG X, REIBLE D. Theoretical analysis of constant voltage mode membrane capacitive deionization for water softening[J]. Membranes, 2021, 11(4): 231.
74	WANG L, LIN S H. Mechanism of selective ion removal in membrane capacitive deionization for water softening[J]. Environmental Science & Technology, 2019, 53(10): 5797-5804.
75	CHOI J, LEE H, HONG S. Capacitive deionization (CDI) integrated with monovalent cation selective membrane for producing divalent cation-rich solution[J]. Desalination, 2016, 400: 38-46.
76	HU H Q, FAN Y Z, LIU H. Hydrogen production using single-chamber membrane-free microbial electrolysis cells[J]. Water Research, 2008, 42(15): 4172-4178.
77	DITZIG J, LIU H, LOGAN B E. Production of hydrogen from domestic wastewater using a bioelectrochemically assisted microbial reactor (BEAMR)[J]. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2007, 32(13): 2296-2304.
78	NAM J Y, JWA E, KIM D, et al. Selective removal of multivalent ions from seawater by bioelectrochemical system[J]. Desalination, 2015, 359: 37-40.
79	LEI Y, HIDAYAT I, SAAKES M, et al. Fate of calcium, magnesium and inorganic carbon in electrochemical phosphorus recovery from domestic wastewater[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2019, 362: 453-459.
80	KYAZZE G, POPOV A, DINSDALE R, et al. Influence of catholyte pH and temperature on hydrogen production from acetate using a two chamber concentric tubular microbial electrolysis cell[J]. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2010, 35(15): 7716-7722.
81	JWA E, YUN Y M, KIM H, et al. Domestic wastewater treatment in a tubular microbial electrolysis cell with a membrane electrode assembly[J]. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2019, 44(2): 652-660.
82	JWA E, YUN Y M, KIM H, et al. Energy-efficient seawater softening and power generation using a microbial electrolysis cell-reverse electrodialysis hybrid system[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2020, 391: 123480.
83	LI X H, MO Y H, QING W H, et al. Membrane-based technologies for lithium recovery from water lithium resources: a review[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2019, 591: 117317.
84	黄清波, 刘公平, 金万勤. 一/二价离子分离膜材料研究进展[J]. 化工学报, 2021, 72(1): 334-350.
	HUANG Qingbo, LIU Gongping, JIN Wanqin. Recent progress of membrane materials for mono-/di-valent ions separation[J]. CIESC Journal, 2021, 72(1): 334-350.
85	TANG Y J, SHEN B J, HUANG B Q, et al. High permselectivity thin-film composite nanofiltration membranes with 3D microstructure fabricated by incorporation of beta cyclodextrin[J]. Separation and Purification Technology, 2019, 227: 115718.
86	GONG G H, WANG P, ZHOU Z Y, et al. New insights into the role of an interlayer for the fabrication of highly selective and permeable thin-film composite nanofiltration membrane[J]. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2019, 11(7): 7349-7356.
87	YAO Z K, GUO H, YANG Z, et al. Preparation of nanocavity-contained thin film composite nanofiltration membranes with enhanced permeability and divalent to monovalent ion selectivity[J]. Desalination, 2018, 445: 115-122.
88	YUAN B B, LI P F, WANG P, et al. Novel aliphatic polyamide membrane with high mono-/divalent ion selectivity, excellent Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺ rejection, and improved antifouling properties[J]. Separation and Purification Technology, 2019, 224: 443-455.
89	AN S S, LIU J, WANG J H, et al. Synthesis and characterization of organic-inorganic cross-linked membrane for the separation of mono-charged and double charged ions using UV irradiation[J]. Desalination, 2019, 464: 8-17.
90	JIANG C X, ZHANG D Y, MUHAMMAD A S, et al. Fouling deposition as an effective approach for preparing monovalent selective membranes[J]. Journal of Membrane Science, 2019, 580: 327-335.
91	杨丰瑞, 王志, 燕方正, 等. 纳滤用于一价/二价无机盐溶液分离研究进展[J]. 化工学报, 2021, 72(2): 799-813.
	YANG Fengrui, WANG Zhi, YAN Fangzheng, et al. Progress in separation of monovalent/divalent inorganic salt solutions by nanofiltration[J]. CIESC Journal, 2021, 72(2): 799-813.

[1]	YE Haixing, CHEN Yuhao, CHEN Yi, SUN Haixiang, NIU Qingshan. Research progress of composite nanofiltration membrane for magnesium and lithium separation [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(4): 1934-1943.
[2]	YANG Kailu, CHEN Mingxing, WANG Xinya, ZHANG Wei, XIAO Changfa. Research progress of preparation and modification of nanofiltration membrane for dye wastewater treatment [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(10): 5470-5486.
[3]	WANG Yan, QIN Zhenping, LIU Yue, ZHANG Wenhai, GUO Hongxia. Preparation and properties of β-cyclodextrin in-situ modified MoS₂ tubular ceramic composite membrane [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2023, 42(10): 5373-5380.
[4]	WANG Zhi, YUAN Ye, SHENG Menglong, LI Qinghua. Membrane technology for carbon capture—Research status and prospects [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2022, 41(3): 1097-1101.
[5]	MENG Xiangwei, WU Xiaoli, GAO Zhanpeng, LI Wenpeng, WANG Jingtao. Preparation and organic solvent nanofiltration performance of vermiculite lamellar membranes [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2022, 41(11): 5986-5995.
[6]	LI Zehui, CUI Heng, WANG Jun. Preparation of CPVC composite nanofiltration membrane and its application in simulated RB5 dye wastewater treatment [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2021, 40(S1): 456-465.
[7]	LI Zhilu, WANG Min, ZHAO Youjing, PENG Zhengjun, BAI Lu. Effects of membrane characteristics for lithium extraction [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2021, 40(9): 5061-5072.
[8]	CHEN Yuhao, LIU Jiahui, LIU Juan, ZHANG Hongbin, SUN Haixiang. Research progress of novel composite nanofiltration membrane [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2021, 40(5): 2665-2675.
[9]	JIN Yehao, FENG Xiaoquan, ZHU Junyong, ZHANG Yatao. Research progress in transfer models and membrane materials for organic solvent nanofiltration [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2021, 40(11): 6181-6194.
[10]	HAI Yuyan, HE Can, MA Rui, XIONG Rihua. A review on RO/NF membrane autopsy and membrane fouling diagnosis [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2021, 40(10): 5720-5729.
[11]	ZHAO Dongsheng. Research progress in molybdenum disulfide nanosheet-based NF/RO membranes for water treatment [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2021, 40(10): 5590-5599.
[12]	Ziyang LIU, Zhenping QIN, Suping CUI, Mengmeng JIA, Quanfu AN, Naixin WANG, Yan LIU, Hongxia GUO. Effect of wettability of organic solvent nanofiltration membrane on its permeability and separation performance [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2020, 39(7): 2715-2723.
[13]	Yang CAO, Yuling REN, Shiwei GUO, Yinhua WAN, Jianquan LUO. Research progress on process optimization for preparation of polyamide thin-film composite membrane by interfacial polymerization [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2020, 39(6): 2125-2134.
[14]	Yifang MI, Quanfu AN. Progress in optimization of polyamide nanofiltration membranes prepared by interfacial polymerization for perm-selectivity [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2020, 39(6): 2093-2104.
[15]	Jiasheng XU, Jianguo XIE, Yan LU, Jie REN, Shuang CHEN. Membrane fouling characteristics of disk-tube nanofiltration membrane to domestic water treatment [J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress, 2020, 39(5): 2000-2008.